Dontopedia

A O Herbert

From Dontopedia, the open, paraconsistent wiki. (Last updated 2026-05-06.)

A O Herbert has 29 facts recorded in Dontopedia across 9 references, with 2 live disagreements.

29 facts·19 predicates·9 sources·2 in dispute

Mostly:commissioner for railways(6), is commissioner for railways(4), role(3)

Maturity scale raw canonical shape-checked rule-derived certified

Inbound mentions (17)

Other subjects in dontopedia point AT this entity as a value. These are inverse relationships — e.g. "X motherOf this subject" — and answer questions the forward facts can't. Grouped by predicate.

issuedByIssued by(3)

signedBySigned by(3)

alteredDueToOfficialDecisionAltered Due to Official Decision(1)

announcedByAnnounced by(1)

authorizedByAuthorized by(1)

commissionerCommissioner(1)

commissionerA-o-herbertCommissioner a O Herbert(1)

commissionerForRailwaysCommissioner for Railways(1)

hasCommissionerHas Commissioner(1)

instructionsFromInstructions From(1)

offeredToOffered to(1)

reportsReports(1)

willBeOfferedToWill Be Offered to(1)

Other facts (29)

The long tail: predicates that appear too rarely to warrant their own section. Filter or scroll to find a specific one. Each row links to its source.

29 facts
PredicateValueRef
Commissioner for Railwaystrue[1]
Commissioner for RailwaysSouthern and Western Railway[3]
Commissioner for RailwaysTrue[3]
Commissioner for Railwaystrue[5]
Commissioner for Railwaystrue[4]
Commissioner for Railwaysnull[9]
Is Commissioner for Railwaysnull[4]
Is Commissioner for Railwaysnull[3]
Is Commissioner for Railways{}[4]
Is Commissioner for Railwaystrue[4]
RoleCommissioner for Railways[1]
RoleCommissioner for Railways[3]
RoleCommissioner for Railways[4]
Current PositionCommissioner for Railways[2]
Is Commissioner forRailways[4]
Is CommissionerSouthern and Western Railway[3]
Holds PositionCommissioner for Railways[4]
Signed on1883-05-14[4]
Commissioner forrailways[4]
Signs NoticeSouthern and Western Railway Train Alteration[3]
Has RoleCommissioner for Railways[3]
OfferedUnder Secretary for Railways[3]
Not Yet AcceptedUnder Secretary for Railways[3]
Declined to AcceptUnder Secretary for Lands[3]
Considered atLast Cabinet Meeting[6]
Has Connection WithRailway Department[6]
IsCommissioner for Railways[7]
Demanded Reinstate AsCommissioner Railways[8]
Has Not Acceptedtrue[8]

Timeline

Timeline axis is valid_time — when each source says the fact was true in the world, not when Dontopedia learned about it. Retracted rows are kept for provenance; coloured stripes indicate the context kind.

29 undated
—
roletrove-cooktown/mauritius-queensland
Commissioner for Railways
—
commissionerForRailwaystrove-cooktown/mauritius-queensland
true
—
currentPositiontrove-cooktown/coloured-persons
ex:commissioner-for-railways
—
commissionerForRailwaystrove-cooktown/reynolds
ex:southern-and-western-railway
—
isCommissionerFortrove-cooktown/nunn
ex:railways
—
commissionerForRailwaystrove-cooktown/reynolds
ex:true
—
roletrove-cooktown/reynolds
Commissioner for Railways
—
isCommissionerForRailwaystrove-cooktown/nunn
null
—
commissionerForRailwaystrove-cooktown/watkins
true
—
isCommissionertrove-cooktown/reynolds
ex:southern-and-western-railway
—
holdsPositiontrove-cooktown/nunn
ex:commissioner-for-railways
—
isCommissionerForRailwaystrove-cooktown/reynolds
null
—
signedOntrove-cooktown/nunn
1883-05-14
—
isCommissionerForRailwaystrove-cooktown/nunn
{}
—
commissionerForRailwaystrove-cooktown/nunn
true
—
isCommissionerForRailwaystrove-cooktown/nunn
true
—
roletrove-cooktown/nunn
Commissioner for Railways
—
commissionerFortrove-cooktown/nunn
railways
—
signsNoticetrove-cooktown/reynolds
ex:southern-and-western-railway-train-alteration
—
hasRoletrove-cooktown/reynolds
ex:commissioner-for-railways
—
offeredtrove-cooktown/reynolds
ex:under-secretary-for-railways
—
notYetAcceptedtrove-cooktown/reynolds
ex:under-secretary-for-railways
—
declinedToAccepttrove-cooktown/reynolds
ex:under-secretary-for-lands
—
consideredAttrove-cooktown/north-shore-full
ex:last-cabinet-meeting
—
hasConnectionWithtrove-cooktown/north-shore-full
ex:railway-department
—
isbrackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/trove-new/170386545_Monday-5-November-1883_Advertising
ex:commissioner-for-railways
—
demandedReinstateAsrosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/metadata-reingest/14-trove-nla-gov-au-newspaper-article-292610051-ebcab6e927b9
ex:commissioner-railways
—
hasNotAcceptedrosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/metadata-reingest/14-trove-nla-gov-au-newspaper-article-292610051-ebcab6e927b9
true
—
commissionerForRailwaysrosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/trove-owen-reynolds-carrier-palmer-timeline-884414
null

References (9)

9 references
  1. [1]Mauritius Queensland2 facts
    ctx:genes/trove-cooktown/mauritius-queensland
  2. [2]Coloured Persons1 fact
    ctx:genes/trove-cooktown/coloured-persons
  3. [3]Reynolds10 facts
    ctx:genes/trove-cooktown/reynolds
  4. [4]Nunn9 facts
    ctx:genes/trove-cooktown/nunn
  5. [5]Watkins1 fact
    ctx:genes/trove-cooktown/watkins
  6. [6]North Shore Full2 facts
    ctx:genes/trove-cooktown/north-shore-full
  7. [7]170386545 Monday 5 November 1883 Advertising1 fact
    ctx:genes/brackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/trove-new/170386545_Monday-5-November-1883_Advertising
  8. [8]14 Trove Nla Gov Au Newspaper Article 292610051 Ebcab6e927b92 facts
    ctx:genes/rosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/metadata-reingest/14-trove-nla-gov-au-newspaper-article-292610051-ebcab6e927b9
  9. [9]Trove Owen Reynolds Carrier Palmer Timeline 8844141 fact
    ctx:genes/rosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/trove-owen-reynolds-carrier-palmer-timeline-884414

See also

Keep researching

Missing something or suspicious of what's here? Kick off a research session — a Claude agent will investigate, cite its sources, and file new facts into a dedicated context you can review before accepting into the shared view.

↑