Dontopedia

Circumstantial Evidence

From Dontopedia, the open, paraconsistent wiki. (Last updated 2026-05-20.)

Circumstantial Evidence has 8 facts recorded in Dontopedia across 7 references.

8 facts·8 predicates·7 sources

Mostly:is strong for owen(1), strong for(1), basis for guilt(1)

Maturity scale raw canonical shape-checked rule-derived certified

Inbound mentions (12)

Other subjects in dontopedia point AT this entity as a value. These are inverse relationships — e.g. "X motherOf this subject" — and answer questions the forward facts can't. Grouped by predicate.

evaluatesAsStrongEvaluates As Strong(2)

preferredOverPreferred Over(2)

contrastsWithDirectEvidenceContrasts With Direct Evidence(1)

describesStrengthOfDescribes Strength of(1)

evaluatedAsStrongEvaluated As Strong(1)

foundGuiltyOnFound Guilty on(1)

guiltyBasedOnGuilty Based on(1)

providesProvides(1)

providesBridgeBetweenProvides Bridge Between(1)

reconstructedFromReconstructed From(1)

Other facts (8)

The long tail: predicates that appear too rarely to warrant their own section. Filter or scroll to find a specific one. Each row links to its source.

8 facts
PredicateValueRef
Is Strong for Owentrue[1]
Strong forOwen Reynolds[2]
Basis for GuiltEllen Thompson[3]
SupportsOwen Reynolds Link to Billy[4]
Possibly ProvesIdentity[5]
Supports IdentificationNmp Event 10755[6]
Is Insufficient WithoutCorroborative Evidence[7]
Contrasted WithDirect Evidence[7]

Timeline

Timeline axis is valid_time — when each source says the fact was true in the world, not when Dontopedia learned about it. Retracted rows are kept for provenance; coloured stripes indicate the context kind.

isStrongForOwenedgar-parentage/direct-p3
true
strongForedgar-parentage/v2-p3
ex:owen-reynolds
basisForGuilttrove-cooktown/fallen-women
ex:ellen-thompson
supportsrosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/owen-reynolds-aboriginal-servants-loop-18-negative-search-corrections-checkpoint
ex:owen-reynolds-link-to-billy
possiblyProvesrosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/owen-reynolds-aboriginal-servants-loop-33-cooktown-hospital-billy-mr-reynolds-hos13-22
ex:identity
supportsIdentificationrosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-0145-eid-10755
ex:nmp-event-10755
isInsufficientWithoutblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32028342--qsa846890-1871-letter-from-aulaire-morisset-to-commissioner-of-police-6-septembe
ex:corroborative-evidence
contrastedWithblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32028342--qsa846890-1871-letter-from-aulaire-morisset-to-commissioner-of-police-6-septembe
ex:direct-evidence

References (7)

7 references
  1. [1]Direct P31 fact
    ctx:genes/edgar-parentage/direct-p3
  2. [2]V2 P31 fact
    ctx:genes/edgar-parentage/v2-p3
  3. [3]Fallen Women1 fact
    ctx:genes/trove-cooktown/fallen-women
  4. ctx:genes/rosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/owen-reynolds-aboriginal-servants-loop-18-negative-search-corrections-checkpoint
  5. ctx:genes/rosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/owen-reynolds-aboriginal-servants-loop-33-cooktown-hospital-billy-mr-reynolds-hos13-22
  6. ctx:genes/rosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-0145-eid-10755
  7. ctx:research/blucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32028342--qsa846890-1871-letter-from-aulaire-morisset-to-commissioner-of-police-6-septembe

See also

Keep researching

Missing something or suspicious of what's here? Kick off a research session — a Claude agent will investigate, cite its sources, and file new facts into a dedicated context you can review before accepting into the shared view.