Mr Herbert

as donto believed on

From Dontopedia, the open, paraconsistent wiki. (Last updated 2026-05-06.)

Mr Herbert has 40 facts recorded in Dontopedia across 13 references, with 5 live disagreements.

40 facts·33 predicates·13 sources·5 in dispute

Mostly:entered position(2), produced(2), is commissioner of railways(2)

Inbound mentions (11)

Other subjects in dontopedia point AT this entity as a value. These are inverse relationships — e.g. "X motherOf this subject" — and answer questions the forward facts can't. Grouped by predicate.

`accompaniedBy`Accompanied by(2)

Hon W Milesex:hon-w-miles
Hon W Milesex:hon-w-miles

`carriedPassenger`Carried Passenger(2)

Leuraex:leura
Ly Ee Moon Shipex:ly-ee-moon-ship

`givesPraiseTo`Gives Praise to(2)

Article Authorex:article-author
Brisbane Courier Article 1883 06 21ex:brisbane-courier-article-1883-06-21

`afterDeclineOfSuggestion`After Decline of Suggestion(1)

Mr Thynne Retiredex:mr-thynne-retired

`duringAbsenceOf`During Absence of(1)

Mr F Curnow Appointmentex:mr-f-curnow-appointment

`hasPassengerDeparture`Has Passenger Departure(1)

Fitzroy Ssex:fitzroy-ss

`rankedNextToPermanentHead`Ranked Next to Permanent Head(1)

Chief Clerk Positionex:chief-clerk-position

`superiorTo`Superior to(1)

Ministerex:minister

Other facts (40)

The long tail: predicates that appear too rarely to warrant their own section. Filter or scroll to find a specific one. Each row links to its source.

40 facts

Predicate	Value	Ref
Entered Position	Commissioner	[4]
Entered Position	Commissioner Role	[9]
Produced	Annual Railway Report	[4]
Produced	Queensland Railways Annual Report 1882	[9]
Is Commissioner of Railways	true	[4]
Is Commissioner of Railways	true	[9]
Has Merits As	Railway Administrator	[4]
Has Merits As	Railway Administrator	[9]
Holds Position	Commissioner for Railways	[5]
Holds Position	Commissioner for Railways	[11]
On Leave	null	[2]
On Leave	Commissioner for Railways	[2]
Expected to Disregard	Professional Advice Engineer in Chief	[6]
Expected to Disregard	Engineer in Chief Advice	[10]
First Colonial Secretary Queensland	null	[1]
Also Premier	null	[1]
Held Office From Separation To1866	null	[1]
Now Permanent Head Colonial Office	null	[1]
Cast As Villain	Play	[2]
Played	Villain of Piece	[2]
Declined to Accept	suggestions as to the examination	[3]
Was Murdered by	Potters Muggers	[4]
Position	Commissioner for Railways	[1]
Was Traffic Manager	null	[6]
Did Not Point Out Objections to	Lack of Sunday Precautions	[6]
Will Not Resume Old Duties	null	[7]
Drove Away	Mr Thallon	[7]
Received Extension of Leave	3 months	[7]
Will Be Provided for in Other Branch	null	[7]
Is Commissioner for Railways	null	[8]
Administers	Queensland Railway Matters	[9]
Furnished	Exhaustive Report on Department	[9]
Prepared Table Showing	Railways Business Seven Years	[9]
Did Not Point Out	Serious Objection to No Precautions	[10]
Entitled to Receive	Engineer in Chief Advice	[10]
Supplies Information on	Sunday Trains Change	[10]
Was	Traffic Manager	[10]
Accompanied Person	Hon W Miles	[11]
Member of Committee	null	[12]
Appeared for	Charles Grant	[13]

Timeline axis is valid_time — when each source says the fact was true in the world, not when Dontopedia learned about it. Retracted rows are kept for provenance; coloured stripes indicate the context kind.

40 undated

—

firstColonialSecretaryQueenslandtrove-cooktown/beche-de-mer

null

—

alsoPremiertrove-cooktown/beche-de-mer

null

—

heldOfficeFromSeparationTo1866trove-cooktown/beche-de-mer

null

—

nowPermanentHeadColonialOfficetrove-cooktown/beche-de-mer

null

—

castAsVillaintrove-cooktown/cingalese

ex:play

—

playedtrove-cooktown/cingalese

ex:villain-of-piece

—

declinedToAccepttrove-cooktown/john-davis

suggestions as to the examination

—

wasMurderedBytrove-cooktown/coloured-persons

ex:potters-muggers

—

enteredPositiontrove-cooktown/coloured-persons

ex:commissioner

—

producedtrove-cooktown/coloured-persons

ex:annual-railway-report

—

isCommissionerOfRailwaystrove-cooktown/coloured-persons

true

—

hasMeritsAstrove-cooktown/coloured-persons

ex:railway-administrator

—

holdsPositiontrove-cooktown/north-shore-cooktown

Commissioner for Railways

—

positiontrove-cooktown/beche-de-mer

Commissioner for Railways

—

onLeavetrove-cooktown/cingalese

null

—

onLeavetrove-cooktown/cingalese

ex:commissioner-for-railways

—

wasTrafficManagertrove-cooktown/nunn

null

—

didNotPointOutObjectionsTotrove-cooktown/nunn

ex:lack-of-sunday-precautions

—

expectedToDisregardtrove-cooktown/nunn

ex:professional-advice-engineer-in-chief

—

willNotResumeOldDutiestrove-cooktown/reynolds

null

—

droveAwaytrove-cooktown/reynolds

ex:mr-thallon

—

receivedExtensionOfLeavetrove-cooktown/reynolds

3 months

—

willBeProvidedForInOtherBranchtrove-cooktown/reynolds

null

—

isCommissionerForRailwaystrove-cooktown/prostitution

null

—

producedbrackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/north-shore-beche-de-mer/3419291_Thursday-21-June-1883

ex:queensland-railways-annual-report-1882

—

administersbrackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/north-shore-beche-de-mer/3419291_Thursday-21-June-1883

ex:queensland-railway-matters

—

furnishedbrackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/north-shore-beche-de-mer/3419291_Thursday-21-June-1883

ex:exhaustive-report-on-department

—

hasMeritsAsbrackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/north-shore-beche-de-mer/3419291_Thursday-21-June-1883

ex:railway-administrator

—

enteredPositionbrackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/north-shore-beche-de-mer/3419291_Thursday-21-June-1883

ex:commissioner-role

—

isCommissionerOfRailwaysbrackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/north-shore-beche-de-mer/3419291_Thursday-21-June-1883

true

—

preparedTableShowingbrackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/north-shore-beche-de-mer/3419291_Thursday-21-June-1883

ex:railways-business-seven-years

—

didNotPointOutbrackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/trove-new/3422704_Saturday-6-October-1883-the-brisbane-courier-saturday-october-6-1883

ex:serious-objection-to-no-precautions

—

expectedToDisregardbrackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/trove-new/3422704_Saturday-6-October-1883-the-brisbane-courier-saturday-october-6-1883

ex:engineer-in-chief-advice

—

entitledToReceivebrackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/trove-new/3422704_Saturday-6-October-1883-the-brisbane-courier-saturday-october-6-1883

ex:engineer-in-chief-advice

—

suppliesInformationOnbrackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/trove-new/3422704_Saturday-6-October-1883-the-brisbane-courier-saturday-october-6-1883

ex:sunday-trains-change

—

wasbrackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/trove-new/3422704_Saturday-6-October-1883-the-brisbane-courier-saturday-october-6-1883

ex:traffic-manager

—

accompaniedPersonbrackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/trove-new/3424421_Tuesday-27-November-1883-queensland-news-from-our-own-correspondents-toowoomba-novemb

ex:hon-w-miles

—

holdsPositionbrackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/trove-new/3424421_Tuesday-27-November-1883-queensland-news-from-our-own-correspondents-toowoomba-novemb

ex:commissioner-for-railways

—

memberOfCommitteebrackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/trove-new/84122305_Thursday-15-October-1903-charters-towers

null

—

appearedForbrackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/trove-new/171029840_Saturday-16-May-1891_GENERAL-NEWS

ex:charles-grant

References (13)

13 references

[1]Beche De Mer5 facts
ctx:genes/trove-cooktown/beche-de-mer
[2]Cingalese4 facts
ctx:genes/trove-cooktown/cingalese
[3]John Davis1 fact
ctx:genes/trove-cooktown/john-davis
[4]Coloured Persons5 facts
ctx:genes/trove-cooktown/coloured-persons
[5]North Shore Cooktown1 fact
ctx:genes/trove-cooktown/north-shore-cooktown
[6]Nunn3 facts
ctx:genes/trove-cooktown/nunn
[7]Reynolds4 facts
ctx:genes/trove-cooktown/reynolds
[8]Prostitution1 fact
ctx:genes/trove-cooktown/prostitution
[9]3419291 Thursday 21 June 18837 facts
ctx:genes/brackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/north-shore-beche-de-mer/3419291_Thursday-21-June-1883
[10]3422704 Saturday 6 October 1883 the Brisbane Courier Saturday October 6 18835 facts
ctx:genes/brackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/trove-new/3422704_Saturday-6-October-1883-the-brisbane-courier-saturday-october-6-1883
[11]3424421 Tuesday 27 November 1883 Queensland News From Our Own Correspondents Toowoomba Novemb2 facts
ctx:genes/brackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/trove-new/3424421_Tuesday-27-November-1883-queensland-news-from-our-own-correspondents-toowoomba-novemb
[12]84122305 Thursday 15 October 1903 Charters Towers1 fact
ctx:genes/brackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/trove-new/84122305_Thursday-15-October-1903-charters-towers
[13]171029840 Saturday 16 May 1891 General News1 fact
ctx:genes/brackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/trove-new/171029840_Saturday-16-May-1891_GENERAL-NEWS

Keep researching

Missing something or suspicious of what's here? Kick off a research session — a Claude agent will investigate, cite its sources, and file new facts into a dedicated context you can review before accepting into the shared view.

Mr Herbert

Inbound mentions (11)

accompaniedByAccompanied by(2)

carriedPassengerCarried Passenger(2)

givesPraiseToGives Praise to(2)

afterDeclineOfSuggestionAfter Decline of Suggestion(1)

duringAbsenceOfDuring Absence of(1)

hasPassengerDepartureHas Passenger Departure(1)

rankedNextToPermanentHeadRanked Next to Permanent Head(1)

superiorToSuperior to(1)

Other facts (40)

Timeline

References (13)

See also

Keep researching

`accompaniedBy`Accompanied by(2)

`carriedPassenger`Carried Passenger(2)

`givesPraiseTo`Gives Praise to(2)

`afterDeclineOfSuggestion`After Decline of Suggestion(1)

`duringAbsenceOf`During Absence of(1)

`hasPassengerDeparture`Has Passenger Departure(1)

`rankedNextToPermanentHead`Ranked Next to Permanent Head(1)

`superiorTo`Superior to(1)