From Dontopedia, the open, paraconsistent wiki. (Last updated 2026-05-07.)
Mr Justice Chubb has 89 facts recorded in Dontopedia across 10 references, with 6 live disagreements.
Mostly:commented severely on(3), gave decision in(2), ordered appearance(2)
orderedAppearancereceivedLetterisSupremeCourtJudgemadeRemarksreceivedExtraordinaryLetterReaddressedisChairmanOfdeclaredLetterAsevaluatesLetterNegativelysummedUpAgainstDefendantOther subjects in dontopedia point AT this entity as a value. These are inverse relationships — e.g. “X motherOf this subject” — and answer questions the forward facts can't. Grouped by predicate.
beforeJudgeBefore Judge(3)ex:circuit-court-charters-towersex:circuit-court-mackayex:october-sittings-circuit-courtopenedBeforeOpened Before(2)ex:mackay-supreme-courtex:supreme-court-cooktowncarriedPassengerCarried Passenger(1)ex:ship-arawattacarriedPassengersCarried Passengers(1)ex:birksgatecriminalJurisdictionBeforeJudgeCriminal Jurisdiction Before Judge(1)ex:northern-supreme-courtduringAbsenceOfDuring Absence of(1)ex:judge-noel-appointmentexcusedByExcused by(1)ex:unnamed-jury-manheardBeforeHeard Before(1)ex:dr-lloyd-v-mowbrayinMistakeForIn Mistake for(1)ex:mr-charles-frederick-chubb-biographyjudgeJudge(1)ex:charters-towers-supreme-courtjudgeSummedUpJudge Summed Up(1)ex:f-c-b-vosper-seditious-libel-casepresidedByPresided by(1)ex:circuit-court-charters-towersprovidedAdditionalJudgeProvided Additional Judge(1)ex:supreme-courtreceivedByReceived by(1)ex:extraordinary-letter-to-mr-justice-chubbrelievesRelieves(1)ex:chief-justice-circuit-reliefrelievingRelieving(1)ex:judge-noeltoAppearBeforeTo Appear Before(1)ex:john-hopkinsThe long tail: predicates that appear too rarely to warrant their own section. Filter or scroll to find a specific one. Each row links to its source.
| Predicate | Value | Ref |
|---|---|---|
| Summed Up Dead Against | null | [10] |
| Called | ignorant as laymen | [5] |
| Criticized | Police Magistrate | [5] |
| Expressed Astonishment | at ignorance | [5] |
| Presided Over | Supreme Court Monday | [5] |
| Declared Codicil Does Not Affect | Elizabeth Melkle | [6] |
| Delivered Decision on | Romberg Will Case | [6] |
| Reason Condition Not Exist | husband not dead | [6] |
| Reason Gift Void | illegal and immoral conditions | [6] |
| Departs Brisbane on | Saturday-next-week-1895 | [4] |
| Takes Circuit | Bundaberg Maryborough Rockhampton Circuit | [4] |
| Concurred With | Maru Verdict | [5] |
| Opened Court | Cairns Circuit Court | [5] |
| Ordered | John Hopkins | [3] |
| Considered Case of | Mr John Hopkins | [3] |
| Found | Mr John Hopkins Sane | [3] |
| Issued Order for | Mr John Hopkins to Appear Before Court | [3] |
| Located at | Townsville | [3] |
| Threatens Committal | Contempt Prison | [5] |
| Threatened Contempt Charge | Townsville Case Letter Writer | [5] |
| Adjourned Matter Sine Die | True | [4] |
| Declared Letter | monstrous contempt of Court | [7] |
| Read Letter in Court | Supreme Court Townsville | [7] |
| Received Extraordinary Letter | Unsigned Letter Insolvency Case | [7] |
| Declined Certificate of Discharge to | Thomas Reedy | [4] |
| In Supreme Court Today | Townsville | [4] |
| Reason No Particulars of | Brady's private estate | [4] |
| Passenger on | Wodonga | [1] |
| Opinion Land for Church Purposes | not exempted from rating | [4] |
| Opinion Land Liable to Rating | {} | [4] |
| Ruled Justices Wrong | {} | [4] |
| Arrived in | Brisbane | [3] |
| Is Northern Supreme Court Judge | null | [3] |
| Complimented | Constable M Kiernan | [3] |
| Arrived at | Cairns | [5] |
| Arrived on | Sunday Before May 9 1892 | [5] |
| Is Absent for | Appeal Cases Full Court | [3] |
| Addressing Prisoner Said | Ah Sec | [3] |
| Before Sentencing | Ah Sec | [3] |
| Believes Unfortunately for Prisoner | he was a Chinaman | [3] |
| Expresses Belief in | racial disparity in justice | [3] |
| Opinion on Case Formed | immediately after hearing prisoner's case | [3] |
| Thought Would Have Been | acquitted had he been a white man | [3] |
| Addressed Prisoner | Ah See | [3] |
| Forms Opinion of | Case After Ah See | [3] |
| Opinion That | unfortunately for him he was a Chinaman | [3] |
| Remarks in Consequence of | Verdict Acquitting Philo Milton | [3] |
| Criticizes Severely Lack of Gas | null | [4] |
| Will Decline to Sit in Dark | null | [4] |
| Would Lock Up Juries | null | [4] |
| Disagreed With Verdict | Phillo Multon Verdict | [3] |
| Made Caustic Remarks | Ah See Sentencing | [3] |
| Stated Evidence Showed | manslaughter | [3] |
| Stated Law No Respect for Persons | especially against Chinaman on Charters Towers | [3] |
| Would Have Passed | moderate sentence | [3] |
| Would Recommend | First Offenders Probation Act | [3] |
| Refused Nonsuit | Mclean V Skeene | [3] |
| Suggested One Jury for Both Cases | Mclean V Skeene Cases | [3] |
| Able Studious Lawyer | null | [1] |
| Character Beyond Reproach | null | [1] |
| Has Character Beyond Reproach | null | [1] |
| Is Able and Studious Lawyer | null | [1] |
| Sworn in on | 3rd instant | [1] |
| Was Never Brilliant Pleader at Bar | null | [1] |
| Court Opening Date | 1894-05-17 | [5] |
| Criticizes Verdict As | racially biased | [3] |
| Believes Would Be | acquitted had he been a white man | [3] |
| Implies Racial Bias | in verdicts | [3] |
| Uses Sarcasm | law no respect especially against Chinaman | [3] |
| Implied Racial Bias | Chinaman vs white man | [3] |
Timeline axis is valid_time — when each source says the fact was true in the world, not when Dontopedia learned about it. Retracted rows are kept for provenance; coloured stripes indicate the context kind.
Dontopedia is in a read-only public launch. Follow the references and disputed branches now; contributions will open after durable identity and moderation are in place.