Mr Kinnaird Rose

as donto believed on

From Dontopedia, the open, paraconsistent wiki. (Last updated 2026-05-06.)

Mr Kinnaird Rose

Succeeded As Editor	Carl Feilberg^[3]
Succeeded As Editor	Mr Carl Feilberg^[6]
Instructed by	Mr Blakeney^[1]
Instructed by	Mr Blakeney Cooktown^[2]
Appeared for	Captain Neil Peter Sorensen^[2]
Appeared for	Peter Sorensen^[2]
Conducted Experiments in	bill-drafting and codification^[5]
Distinguished Himself by Publishing	Panegyric on Sir Samuel Griffith^[5]
Known for Panegyric	null^[5]
Participated in Other Inquiries	true^[5]
Argued Amending Act Limited Jurisdiction	Section 267 Merchant Shipping Act 1854^[2]

ex:mr-kinnaird-rose

Mr Kinnaird Rose has 62 facts recorded in Dontopedia across 6 references, with 3 live disagreements.

62 facts·58 predicates·6 sources·3 in dispute

Mostly:instructed by(3), succeeded as editor(2), appeared for(2)

Succeeded As Editorin dispute`succeededAsEditor`

Carl Feilberg^[3]all time · North Shore Full
Mr Carl Feilberg^[6]all time · 21647211 Saturday 11 July 1903

Instructed byin dispute`instructedBy`

Mr Blakeney^[1]all time · Beche De Mer
Mr Blakeney Cooktown^[2]all time · Douro Vessel
Mr Ruthning^[2]all time · Douro Vessel

Appeared forin dispute`appearedFor`

Captain Neil Peter Sorensen^[2]all time · Douro Vessel
Peter Sorensen^[2]all time · Douro Vessel

Conducted Experiments in`conductedExperimentsIn`

bill-drafting and codification^[5]all time · 146783518 Thursday 3 March 1887 No Title

Distinguished Himself by Publishing`distinguishedHimselfByPublishing`

Panegyric on Sir Samuel Griffith^[5]all time · 146783518 Thursday 3 March 1887 No Title

Known for Panegyric`knownForPanegyric`

null^[5]all time · 146783518 Thursday 3 March 1887 No Title

Participated in Other Inquiries`participatedInOtherInquiries`

true^[5]all time · 146783518 Thursday 3 March 1887 No Title

Argued Amending Act Limited Jurisdiction`arguedAmendingActLimitedJurisdiction`

Section 267 Merchant Shipping Act 1854^[2]all time · Douro Vessel

Argued Information Does Not Specify on Board Ship`arguedInformationDoesNotSpecifyOnBoardShip`

Charge Information Peter Sorensen^[2]all time · Douro Vessel

Cited Case`citedCase`

Regina V Anderson^[2]all time · Douro Vessel

Contended No Jurisdiction Outside Dominions`contendedNoJurisdictionOutsideDominions`

Merchant Shipping Act 1854^[2]all time · Douro Vessel

Quoted Mr Justice Blackburn`quotedMr-justice-blackburn`

Regina V Anderson^[2]all time · Douro Vessel

Inbound mentions (29)

Other subjects in dontopedia point AT this entity as a value. These are inverse relationships — e.g. "X motherOf this subject" — and answer questions the forward facts can't. Grouped by predicate.

`alternativeToOriginal`Alternative to Original(1)

`assumedBritishSubject`Assumed British Subject(1)

Captain Neil Peter Sorensenex:captain-neil-peter-sorensen

`challengedBy`Challenged by(1)

Prosecution Caseex:prosecution-case

`contendedAgainstOralLimits`Contended Against Oral Limits(1)

Mr Lewisex:mr-lewis

`contentsNotByOral`Contents Not by Oral(1)

Written Documentex:written-document

`declinedAnswerOnFraud`Declined Answer on Fraud(1)

Ex:august Thomas Godfrey Leslieex:ex:august-thomas-godfrey-leslie

`dependsOnRegister`Depends on Register(1)

Ownership Proofex:ownership-proof

`distinguishesCases`Distinguishes Cases(1)

Defenseex:defense

`fraudulent`Fraudulent(1)

Flag Transferex:flag-transfer

`hasCounsel`Has Counsel(1)

Niels Peter Sorensenex:niels-peter-sorensen

`insistedOnDocumentary`Insisted on Documentary(1)

Defense Strategyex:defense-strategy

`limitedToSignature`Limited to Signature(1)

Oral Evidenceex:oral-evidence

`multipleOnNationality`Multiple on Nationality(1)

Objection Sequenceex:objection-sequence

`notedObjection`Noted Objection(1)

Police Magistrateex:police-magistrate

`notesObjectionFormally`Notes Objection Formally(1)

Benchex:bench

`objectsProcedurally`Objects Procedurally(1)

Defenseex:defense

`objectsToLeadingQuestion`Objects to Leading Question(1)

Defenseex:defense

`prefersDocumentaryProof`Prefers Documentary Proof(1)

Defenseex:defense

`presupposesFraudIntent`Presupposes Fraud Intent(1)

Nominal Saleex:nominal-sale

`presupposesGermanTerritory`Presupposes German Territory(1)

Admiralty Groupex:admiralty-group

`presupposesRegisterExists`Presupposes Register Exists(1)

British Ownershipex:british-ownership

`presupposesRestrictionsOnFlagChange`Presupposes Restrictions on Flag Change(1)

British Subjectex:british-subject

`recordsObjections`Records Objections(1)

Benchex:bench

`requestsClarity`Requests Clarity(1)

Defenseex:defense

`requiredByLaw`Required by Law(1)

Best Evidenceex:best-evidence

`requiresRegisterOrCertifiedCopy`Requires Register or Certified Copy(1)

Best Evidence Ruleex:best-evidence-rule

`respondsToObjection`Responds to Objection(1)

Mr Lewisex:mr-lewis

`ruledAgainst`Ruled Against(1)

His Honourex:his-honour

`sameAs`Same As(1)

Mr W K Roseex:mr-w-k-rose

Other facts (46)

The long tail: predicates that appear too rarely to warrant their own section. Filter or scroll to find a specific one. Each row links to its source.

46 facts

Predicate	Value	Ref
Disputed	Court Jurisdiction	[2]
Made Argument	Amenable Only Within Hull	[2]
Makes Ingenious Query	Afloat Meaning	[2]
Raised	Technical Points of Law	[2]
Appeared for Accused	Captain Noil Peter Sorensen	[2]
Arrived in	Ging Etam	[3]
Beard Clipped on One Side	Ministerial Supporter	[4]
Accused Witness of	fraud	[1]
Accuses Directly	August Thomas Godfrey Leslie	[1]
Accuses Fraud	August Thomas Godfrey Leslie	[1]
Advocated for	production of ship's register	[1]
Aggressively Cross Examines	August Thomas Godfrey Leslie	[1]
Aware of Legal Axioms	Best Evidence	[1]
Challenges Jurisdiction Strongly	Police Court	[1]
Cited Legal Requirement	certificate of registry or certified copy	[1]
Continues Argument	Police Court	[1]
Criticizes Prosecution Method	cannot prove by oral	[1]
Deems Prosecution Over	case all up	[1]
Disapproves Oral Proof	cannot	[1]
Distinguished Seine As	tidal river equivalent to high seas	[1]
Distinguishes Precedent	Seine Case	[1]
Interposes Objection	Police Court	[1]
Interprets Papers As Foreign	Ships Papers	[1]
Objected to Jurisdiction Because	foreign ship, foreigner on foreigners in German territory	[1]
Objected to Question on Ownership	without registry certificate	[1]
Objects to Jurisdiction Hearing	Robbery Charge	[1]
Objects to Ownership Question	Bench	[1]
Quoted From	Roscoe on Venue page 253	[1]
Quotes Authority	Roscoe on Venue	[1]
Raised Objection About	proving nationality of ship by oral evidence	[1]
Role in Case	defense counsel instructed by Mr. Blakeney of Cooktown	[1]
Submits Case Dismissal	Prosecution	[1]
Submitted Prosecution Case Failed	after evidence on nationality	[1]
Views Transfer Fraudulent	evidently a fraud	[1]
Warned of Penalty	August Thomas Godfrey Leslie	[1]
Warns Severe Penalty	British Subject	[1]
Alternative Argument	even if British, no jurisdiction in foreign sea	[1]
Claims No Jurisdiction Because	accused foreigner, Douro foreign vessel	[1]
Criticizes Jurisdiction Claim	Mr Pinnock Decision	[1]
Defended Accused	Captain Neil Peter Sorensen	[1]
Objected to Jurisdiction Hearing	without hearing on jurisdiction	[1]
Lacks Halo of Sagacity or Impartiality	null	[5]
Challenged Jurisdiction Causally Leading to	Mr Justice Moin Ruling	[2]
Presents Strong Argument	Hull Jurisdiction Argument	[2]
Rhetorically Questioned	Afloat Examples	[2]
Commits to Legal Positivism	null	[1]

Timeline axis is valid_time — when each source says the fact was true in the world, not when Dontopedia learned about it. Retracted rows are kept for provenance; coloured stripes indicate the context kind.

62 undated

—

accusedWitnessOftrove-cooktown/beche-de-mer

fraud

—

accusesDirectlytrove-cooktown/beche-de-mer

ex:august-thomas-godfrey-leslie

—

accusesFraudtrove-cooktown/beche-de-mer

ex:august-thomas-godfrey-leslie

—

advocatedFortrove-cooktown/beche-de-mer

production of ship's register

—

aggressivelyCrossExaminestrove-cooktown/beche-de-mer

ex:august-thomas-godfrey-leslie

—

alternativeArgumenttrove-cooktown/beche-de-mer

even if British, no jurisdiction in foreign sea

—

appearedFortrove-cooktown/douro-vessel

ex:captain-neil-peter-sorensen

—

appearedFortrove-cooktown/douro-vessel

ex:peter-sorensen

—

appearedForAccusedtrove-cooktown/douro-vessel

ex:captain-noil-peter-sorensen

—

arguedAmendingActLimitedJurisdictiontrove-cooktown/douro-vessel

ex:section-267-merchant-shipping-act-1854

—

arguedInformationDoesNotSpecifyOnBoardShiptrove-cooktown/douro-vessel

ex:charge-information-peter-sorensen

—

arrivedIntrove-cooktown/north-shore-full

ex:ging-etam

—

awareOfLegalAxiomstrove-cooktown/beche-de-mer

ex:best-evidence

—

beardClippedOnOneSidetrove-cooktown/cingalese

ex:ministerial-supporter

—

challengedJurisdictionCausallyLeadingTotrove-cooktown/douro-vessel

ex:mr-justice-moin-ruling

—

challengesJurisdictionStronglytrove-cooktown/beche-de-mer

ex:police-court

—

citedCasetrove-cooktown/douro-vessel

ex:regina-v-anderson

—

citedLegalRequirementtrove-cooktown/beche-de-mer

certificate of registry or certified copy

—

claimsNoJurisdictionBecausetrove-cooktown/beche-de-mer

accused foreigner, Douro foreign vessel

—

commitsToLegalPositivismtrove-cooktown/beche-de-mer

null

—

conductedExperimentsInbrackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/trove-new/146783518_Thursday-3-March-1887_No-title

bill-drafting and codification

—

contendedNoJurisdictionOutsideDominionstrove-cooktown/douro-vessel

ex:merchant-shipping-act-1854

—

continuesArgumenttrove-cooktown/beche-de-mer

ex:police-court

—

criticizesJurisdictionClaimtrove-cooktown/beche-de-mer

ex:mr-pinnock-decision

—

criticizesProsecutionMethodtrove-cooktown/beche-de-mer

cannot prove by oral

—

deemsProsecutionOvertrove-cooktown/beche-de-mer

case all up

—

defendedAccusedtrove-cooktown/beche-de-mer

ex:captain-neil-peter-sorensen

—

disapprovesOralProoftrove-cooktown/beche-de-mer

cannot

—

disputedtrove-cooktown/douro-vessel

ex:court-jurisdiction

—

distinguishedHimselfByPublishingbrackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/trove-new/146783518_Thursday-3-March-1887_No-title

ex:panegyric-on-sir-samuel-griffith

—

distinguishedSeineAstrove-cooktown/beche-de-mer

tidal river equivalent to high seas

—

distinguishesPrecedenttrove-cooktown/beche-de-mer

ex:seine-case

—

instructedBytrove-cooktown/beche-de-mer

ex:mr-blakeney

—

instructedBytrove-cooktown/douro-vessel

ex:mr-blakeney-cooktown

—

instructedBytrove-cooktown/douro-vessel

ex:mr-ruthning

—

interposesObjectiontrove-cooktown/beche-de-mer

ex:police-court

—

interpretsPapersAsForeigntrove-cooktown/beche-de-mer

ex:ships-papers

—

knownForPanegyricbrackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/trove-new/146783518_Thursday-3-March-1887_No-title

null

—

lacksHaloOfSagacityOrImpartialitybrackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/trove-new/146783518_Thursday-3-March-1887_No-title

null

—

madeArgumenttrove-cooktown/douro-vessel

ex:amenable-only-within-hull

—

makesIngeniousQuerytrove-cooktown/douro-vessel

ex:afloat-meaning

—

objectedToJurisdictionBecausetrove-cooktown/beche-de-mer

foreign ship, foreigner on foreigners in German territory

—

objectedToJurisdictionHearingtrove-cooktown/beche-de-mer

without hearing on jurisdiction

—

objectedToQuestionOnOwnershiptrove-cooktown/beche-de-mer

without registry certificate

—

objectsToJurisdictionHearingtrove-cooktown/beche-de-mer

ex:robbery-charge

—

objectsToOwnershipQuestiontrove-cooktown/beche-de-mer

ex:bench

—

participatedInOtherInquiriesbrackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/trove-new/146783518_Thursday-3-March-1887_No-title

true

—

presentsStrongArgumenttrove-cooktown/douro-vessel

ex:hull-jurisdiction-argument

—

quotedFromtrove-cooktown/beche-de-mer

Roscoe on Venue page 253

—

quotedMr-justice-blackburntrove-cooktown/douro-vessel

ex:regina-v-anderson

—

quotesAuthoritytrove-cooktown/beche-de-mer

ex:roscoe-on-venue

—

raisedtrove-cooktown/douro-vessel

ex:technical-points-of-law

—

raisedObjectionAbouttrove-cooktown/beche-de-mer

proving nationality of ship by oral evidence

—

rhetoricallyQuestionedtrove-cooktown/douro-vessel

ex:afloat-examples

—

roleInCasetrove-cooktown/beche-de-mer

defense counsel instructed by Mr. Blakeney of Cooktown

—

submitsCaseDismissaltrove-cooktown/beche-de-mer

ex:prosecution

—

submittedProsecutionCaseFailedtrove-cooktown/beche-de-mer

after evidence on nationality

—

succeededAsEditortrove-cooktown/north-shore-full

ex:carl-feilberg

—

succeededAsEditorbrackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/north-shore-reynolds/21647211_Saturday-11-July-1903

ex:mr-carl-feilberg

—

viewsTransferFraudulenttrove-cooktown/beche-de-mer

evidently a fraud

—

warnedOfPenaltytrove-cooktown/beche-de-mer

ex:august-thomas-godfrey-leslie

—

warnsSeverePenaltytrove-cooktown/beche-de-mer

ex:british-subject

References (6)

6 references

[1]Beche De Mer36 facts
customctx:genes/trove-cooktown/beche-de-mer
[2]Douro Vessel17 facts
customctx:genes/trove-cooktown/douro-vessel
[3]North Shore Full2 facts
customctx:genes/trove-cooktown/north-shore-full
[4]Cingalese1 fact
customctx:genes/trove-cooktown/cingalese
[5]146783518 Thursday 3 March 1887 No Title5 facts
customctx:genes/brackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/trove-new/146783518_Thursday-3-March-1887_No-title
[6]21647211 Saturday 11 July 19031 fact
customctx:genes/brackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/north-shore-reynolds/21647211_Saturday-11-July-1903

Keep researching

Missing something or suspicious of what's here? Kick off a research session — a Claude agent will investigate, cite its sources, and file new facts into a dedicated context you can review before accepting into the shared view.

Mr Kinnaird Rose

Succeeded As Editorin disputesucceededAsEditor

Instructed byin disputeinstructedBy

Appeared forin disputeappearedFor

Conducted Experiments inconductedExperimentsIn

Distinguished Himself by PublishingdistinguishedHimselfByPublishing

Known for PanegyricknownForPanegyric

Participated in Other InquiriesparticipatedInOtherInquiries

Argued Amending Act Limited JurisdictionarguedAmendingActLimitedJurisdiction

Argued Information Does Not Specify on Board ShiparguedInformationDoesNotSpecifyOnBoardShip

Cited CasecitedCase

Contended No Jurisdiction Outside DominionscontendedNoJurisdictionOutsideDominions

Quoted Mr Justice BlackburnquotedMr-justice-blackburn

Inbound mentions (29)

alternativeToOriginalAlternative to Original(1)

assumedBritishSubjectAssumed British Subject(1)

challengedByChallenged by(1)

contendedAgainstOralLimitsContended Against Oral Limits(1)

contentsNotByOralContents Not by Oral(1)

declinedAnswerOnFraudDeclined Answer on Fraud(1)

dependsOnRegisterDepends on Register(1)

distinguishesCasesDistinguishes Cases(1)

fraudulentFraudulent(1)

hasCounselHas Counsel(1)

insistedOnDocumentaryInsisted on Documentary(1)

limitedToSignatureLimited to Signature(1)

multipleOnNationalityMultiple on Nationality(1)

notedObjectionNoted Objection(1)

notesObjectionFormallyNotes Objection Formally(1)

objectsProcedurallyObjects Procedurally(1)

objectsToLeadingQuestionObjects to Leading Question(1)

prefersDocumentaryProofPrefers Documentary Proof(1)

presupposesFraudIntentPresupposes Fraud Intent(1)

presupposesGermanTerritoryPresupposes German Territory(1)

presupposesRegisterExistsPresupposes Register Exists(1)

presupposesRestrictionsOnFlagChangePresupposes Restrictions on Flag Change(1)

recordsObjectionsRecords Objections(1)

requestsClarityRequests Clarity(1)

requiredByLawRequired by Law(1)

requiresRegisterOrCertifiedCopyRequires Register or Certified Copy(1)

respondsToObjectionResponds to Objection(1)

ruledAgainstRuled Against(1)

sameAsSame As(1)

Other facts (46)

Timeline

References (6)

See also

Keep researching

Succeeded As Editorin dispute`succeededAsEditor`

Instructed byin dispute`instructedBy`

Appeared forin dispute`appearedFor`

Conducted Experiments in`conductedExperimentsIn`

Distinguished Himself by Publishing`distinguishedHimselfByPublishing`

Known for Panegyric`knownForPanegyric`

Participated in Other Inquiries`participatedInOtherInquiries`

Argued Amending Act Limited Jurisdiction`arguedAmendingActLimitedJurisdiction`

Argued Information Does Not Specify on Board Ship`arguedInformationDoesNotSpecifyOnBoardShip`

Cited Case`citedCase`

Contended No Jurisdiction Outside Dominions`contendedNoJurisdictionOutsideDominions`

Quoted Mr Justice Blackburn`quotedMr-justice-blackburn`

`alternativeToOriginal`Alternative to Original(1)

`assumedBritishSubject`Assumed British Subject(1)

`challengedBy`Challenged by(1)

`contendedAgainstOralLimits`Contended Against Oral Limits(1)

`contentsNotByOral`Contents Not by Oral(1)

`declinedAnswerOnFraud`Declined Answer on Fraud(1)

`dependsOnRegister`Depends on Register(1)

`distinguishesCases`Distinguishes Cases(1)

`fraudulent`Fraudulent(1)

`hasCounsel`Has Counsel(1)

`insistedOnDocumentary`Insisted on Documentary(1)

`limitedToSignature`Limited to Signature(1)

`multipleOnNationality`Multiple on Nationality(1)

`notedObjection`Noted Objection(1)

`notesObjectionFormally`Notes Objection Formally(1)

`objectsProcedurally`Objects Procedurally(1)

`objectsToLeadingQuestion`Objects to Leading Question(1)

`prefersDocumentaryProof`Prefers Documentary Proof(1)

`presupposesFraudIntent`Presupposes Fraud Intent(1)

`presupposesGermanTerritory`Presupposes German Territory(1)

`presupposesRegisterExists`Presupposes Register Exists(1)

`presupposesRestrictionsOnFlagChange`Presupposes Restrictions on Flag Change(1)

`recordsObjections`Records Objections(1)

`requestsClarity`Requests Clarity(1)

`requiredByLaw`Required by Law(1)

`requiresRegisterOrCertifiedCopy`Requires Register or Certified Copy(1)

`respondsToObjection`Responds to Objection(1)

`ruledAgainst`Ruled Against(1)

`sameAs`Same As(1)