Reliability of Sources
From Dontopedia, the open, paraconsistent wiki. (Last updated 2026-06-03.)
Reliability of Sources has 33 facts recorded in Dontopedia across 26 references, with 2 live disagreements.
33 facts·30 predicates·26 sources·2 in dispute
Mostly:assessed source(3), based on(2), source type(1)
Maturity scale
raw canonical shape-checked rule-derived certifiedBased onin disputebasedOn
- Direct Communication to Mine Manager[3]all time · Row 2218 Eid 62009
- Telegram From Police[4]all time · Row 0803 Eid 21324
Assessed Sourcein disputeassessedSource
- 1914 Account[2]sourceall time · 10620
- Nephew of Thompson Account[2]sourceall time · 10620
- Son of Landowner Account[2]sourceall time · 10620
Source TypesourceType
- eyewitness-account[2]sourceall time · 10620
Son Was Adult at TimesonWasAdultAtTime
- true[2]sourceall time · 10620
Rdfs:labelrdfs:label
- source reliability assessment[2]sourceall time · 10620
Evaluates As Copy of OriginalevaluatesAsCopyOfOriginal
- Letter Written 1877[12]all time · Row 2470 Eid 67128
Evaluates PositivelyevaluatesPositively
- Qsa847310 Letter[14]all time · Row 2472 Eid 67187
High Due tohighDueTo
- Station Manager Account[18]all time · Row 2385 Eid 64164
Based on Settler PerspectivebasedOnSettlerPerspective
- Settler Complaints[8]all time · Row 2302 Eid 63022
Deemed First HanddeemedFirstHand
- Sen Const J O Brien[10]all time · Row 2425 Eid 65102
Evaluated As First HandevaluatedAsFirstHand
- Police Constable Account[11]all time · Row 2424 Eid 65100
Evaluates As Newspaper AccountevaluatesAsNewspaperAccount
- Nmp Event 59090[13]all time · Row 2028 Eid 59090
Other facts (18)
The long tail: predicates that appear too rarely to warrant their own section. Filter or scroll to find a specific one. Each row links to its source.
18 facts
| Predicate | Value | Ref |
|---|---|---|
| Rates As Direct | Nmp Event Eid 54508 | [26] |
| Hedges With Presumably | Flinders Diary | [16] |
| Is Direct Account | Participant | [22] |
| Based on Court Reports | null | [5] |
| Hedges With | some inaccuracies | [15] |
| Based on Eyewitness Report | Cook Eyewitness | [6] |
| Acknowledges Temporal Distance | null | [1] |
| Originates From Local Newspapers | Maytown Newspapers | [23] |
| Hedges With Though Long After | Nmp Event Eid 18729 | [17] |
| Considered Second Hand | Nmp Event Eid 18952 | [9] |
| Strengthened by | Son of Original Owner | [9] |
| Based on Recollections | null | [7] |
| High Due to Presence | Unnamed Constable | [19] |
| Indicates Uncertainty | Nmp Event 64457 | [21] |
| Presumed Direct From Dowling | Nmp Event 69707 | [24] |
| Presupposes Oral Transmission | null | [25] |
| Indicates Certainty | High Certainty Via Multiple Sources | [20] |
| Rdf:type | Assessment | [2] |
Timeline
Timeline axis is valid_time — when each source says the fact was true in the world, not when Dontopedia learned about it. Retracted rows are kept for provenance; coloured stripes indicate the context kind.
—
acknowledgesTemporalDistancerosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-0377-eid-18676
null
—
assessedSourcefrontier-massacres/10620
ex:1914-account
—
assessedSourcefrontier-massacres/10620
ex:nephew-of-thompson-account
—
assessedSourcefrontier-massacres/10620
ex:son-of-landowner-account
—
basedOnrosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-2218-eid-62009
ex:direct-communication-to-mine-manager
—
basedOnrosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-0803-eid-21324
ex:telegram-from-police
—
basedOnCourtReportsrosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-0767-eid-20980
null
—
basedOnEyewitnessReportrosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-0783-eid-21095
ex:cook-eyewitness
—
basedOnRecollectionsrosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-0082-eid-10689
null
—
basedOnSettlerPerspectiverosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-2302-eid-63022
ex:settler-complaints
—
consideredSecondHandrosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-0440-eid-18952
ex:nmp-event-eid-18952
—
deemedFirstHandrosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-2425-eid-65102
ex:sen-const-j-o-brien
—
evaluatedAsFirstHandrosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-2424-eid-65100
ex:police-constable-account
—
evaluatesAsCopyOfOriginalrosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-2470-eid-67128
ex:letter-written-1877
—
evaluatesAsNewspaperAccountrosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-2028-eid-59090
ex:nmp-event-59090
—
evaluatesPositivelyrosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-2472-eid-67187
ex:qsa847310-letter
—
hedgesWithrosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-0827-eid-21593
some inaccuracies
—
hedgesWithPresumablyrosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-1624-eid-50624
ex:flinders-diary
—
hedgesWithThoughLongAfterrosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-0388-eid-18729
ex:nmp-event-eid-18729
—
highDueTorosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-2385-eid-64164
ex:station-manager-account
—
highDueToPresencerosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-2605-eid-69256
ex:unnamed-constable
—
indicatesCertaintyrosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-0213-eid-10832
ex:high-certainty-via-multiple-sources
—
indicatesUncertaintyrosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-2402-eid-64457
ex:nmp-event-64457
—
isDirectAccountrosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-1135-eid-35307
ex:participant
—
originatesFromLocalNewspapersrosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-0341-eid-18437
ex:maytown-newspapers
—
presumedDirectFromDowlingrosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-2639-eid-69707
ex:nmp-event-69707
—
presupposesOralTransmissionrosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-1219-eid-37847
null
—
ratesAsDirectrosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-1918-eid-54508
ex:nmp-event-eid-54508
—
labelfrontier-massacres/10620
source reliability assessment
—
typefrontier-massacres/10620
ex:Assessment
—
sonWasAdultAtTimefrontier-massacres/10620
true
—
sourceTypefrontier-massacres/10620
eyewitness-account
—
strengthenedByrosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-0440-eid-18952
ex:son-of-original-owner
References (26)
26 references
- custom
ctx:genes/rosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-0377-eid-18676 - custom
ctx:genealogy/frontier-massacres/10620- full textctx:genealogy/frontier-massacres/10620text/plain11 KB
doc:genealogy/frontier-massacres/10620Show excerpt
# Frontier conflict event: Attack on Europeans/others - Frederick Toll at Goose Lagoons, Gooraganga (also Goorganga), Proserpine (25 March 1875) Source dataset: University of Newcastle, "Colonial Frontier Massacres in Australia 1788-1930" …
- custom
ctx:genes/rosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-2218-eid-62009 - custom
ctx:genes/rosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-0803-eid-21324 - custom
ctx:genes/rosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-0767-eid-20980 - custom
ctx:genes/rosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-0783-eid-21095 - custom
ctx:genes/rosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-0082-eid-10689 - custom
ctx:genes/rosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-2302-eid-63022 - custom
ctx:genes/rosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-0440-eid-18952 - custom
ctx:genes/rosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-2425-eid-65102 - [11]ctx:genes/rosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-2424-eid-651001 factcustom
ctx:genes/rosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-2424-eid-65100- full textctx:genes/rosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-2424-eid-65100text/plain4 KB
doc:genes/rosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-2424-eid-65100Show excerpt
--- source_url: https://nmp.essolutions.com.au/ source_title: NMP authenticated Events export 2026-05-08 row 2424 EntryId 65100 source_type: authenticated-database-csv-single-row archive_file: research-notes/cooktown-aboriginal-children-wor…
- custom
ctx:genes/rosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-2470-eid-67128 - custom
ctx:genes/rosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-2028-eid-59090 - custom
ctx:genes/rosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-2472-eid-67187 - custom
ctx:genes/rosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-0827-eid-21593 - custom
ctx:genes/rosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-1624-eid-50624 ctx:genes/rosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-0388-eid-18729ctx:genes/rosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-2385-eid-64164ctx:genes/rosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-2605-eid-69256ctx:genes/rosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-0213-eid-10832ctx:genes/rosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-2402-eid-64457ctx:genes/rosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-1135-eid-35307ctx:genes/rosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-0341-eid-18437ctx:genes/rosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-2639-eid-69707ctx:genes/rosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-1219-eid-37847ctx:genes/rosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-1918-eid-54508
See also
- 1914 Account
- Nephew of Thompson Account
- Son of Landowner Account
- Direct Communication to Mine Manager
- Telegram From Police
- Cook Eyewitness
- Settler Complaints
- Nmp Event Eid 18952
- Sen Const J O Brien
- Police Constable Account
- Letter Written 1877
- Nmp Event 59090
- Qsa847310 Letter
- Flinders Diary
- Nmp Event Eid 18729
- Station Manager Account
- Unnamed Constable
- High Certainty Via Multiple Sources
- Nmp Event 64457
- Participant
- Maytown Newspapers
- Nmp Event 69707
- Nmp Event Eid 54508
- Assessment
- Son of Original Owner
Keep researching
Missing something or suspicious of what's here? Kick off a research session — a Claude agent will investigate, cite its sources, and file new facts into a dedicated context you can review before accepting into the shared view.