Valley Railway

as donto believed on

From Dontopedia, the open, paraconsistent wiki. (Last updated 2026-07-03.)

Valley Railway

Length in Miles	2^[1]
Length in Miles	3^[1]
Rdf:type	Infrastructure^[1]
Rdf:type	Railway^[1]
Dependent on Regulation	Traffic Regulation^[3]
Opening Discussed	Creek Street^[3]
Being Hurried	null^[2]
Half Million Cost	null^[2]
Involves	half-a-million of money^[2]
Involves Cost of	£320,000^[2]

ex:valley-railway

Valley Railway has 51 facts recorded in Dontopedia across 5 references, with 2 live disagreements.

51 facts·48 predicates·5 sources·2 in dispute

Mostly:length in miles(2), rdf:type(2), funding voted(2)

Length in Milesin dispute`lengthInMiles`

2^[1]all time · 01203ffc 4446 4e9f 9b21 65587067f0df
3^[1]all time · 01203ffc 4446 4e9f 9b21 65587067f0df

Rdf:typein dispute`rdf:type`

Infrastructure^[1]all time · 01203ffc 4446 4e9f 9b21 65587067f0df
Railway^[1]sourceall time · 01203ffc 4446 4e9f 9b21 65587067f0df

Dependent on Regulation`dependentOnRegulation`

Traffic Regulation^[3]all time · Prostitution

Opening Discussed`openingDiscussed`

Creek Street^[3]all time · Prostitution

Being Hurried`beingHurried`

null^[2]all time · Storekeeper Cooktown

Half Million Cost`halfMillionCost`

null^[2]all time · Storekeeper Cooktown

Involves`involves`

half-a-million of money^[2]all time · Storekeeper Cooktown

Involves Cost of`involvesCostOf`

£320,000^[2]all time · Storekeeper Cooktown

Report of`reportOf`

Select Committee^[2]all time · Storekeeper Cooktown

Discussed Opening to`discussedOpeningTo`

Creek Street^[4]all time · Malay Cooktown

Funding Voted`fundingVoted`

80000^[5]all time · Coloured Persons
80000^[5]all time · Coloured Persons

Proposed Route Through`proposedRouteThrough`

Center of Valley to Bulimba^[5]all time · Coloured Persons

Inbound mentions (17)

Other subjects in dontopedia point AT this entity as a value. These are inverse relationships — e.g. "X motherOf this subject" — and answer questions the forward facts can't. Grouped by predicate.

`associatedWith`Associated With(2)

Blasting Operationsex:blasting-operations
Swindling of Peopleex:swindling-of-people

`lackedActionOn`Lacked Action on(2)

F Beattieex:f-beattie
Mr Beattieex:mr-beattie

`accessibleBy`Accessible by(1)

Mark Wells Paddockex:mark-wells-paddock

`causedBy`Caused by(1)

Swindling of Peopleex:swindling-of-people

`criticizesCarelessness`Criticizes Carelessness(1)

Blasting Incidentex:blasting-incident

`determinedToAchieve`Determined to Achieve(1)

John Watsonex:john-watson

`passed`Passed(1)

Houseex:house

`passedJobsLike`Passed Jobs Like(1)

Houseex:house

`plunderedBy`Plundered by(1)

Peopleex:people

`presupposesNeedFor`Presupposes Need for(1)

Fortitude Valleyex:fortitude-valley

`produced`Produced(1)

Valley Railway Constructionex:valley-railway-construction

`promisedToOpen`Promised to Open(1)

Ministerex:minister

`publiclyExpressedViewOnPlatformAbout`Publicly Expressed View on Platform About(1)

John Watsonex:john-watson

`resultedIn`Resulted in(1)

Valley Railway Constructionex:valley-railway-construction

`swindledBy`Swindled by(1)

Peopleex:people

Other facts (36)

The long tail: predicates that appear too rarely to warrant their own section. Filter or scroll to find a specific one. Each row links to its source.

36 facts

Predicate	Value	Ref
Financially Risky Now	null	[3]
Railway Speculation	null	[3]
Should Be on	That Line	[3]
Had to Be Perfected by Having Station Suitable to It	true	[1]
As It Had Been Made	true	[1]
Should Be for Them to Divide Shame and Blame	true	[1]
People Had Been Swindled and Plundered	true	[1]
Was Entirely Work of Present Opposition	true	[1]
Length Two or Three Miles	two or three miles	[1]
Cost110000	110000	[1]
People Were Plundered	true	[1]
People Were Swindled	true	[1]
Was Scandalous	true	[1]
Length	two or three miles	[1]
Cost	110000	[1]
Nicknamed	cursed Valley railway	[1]
Ought Never to Have Been Made	true	[1]
Work of	Present Opposition	[1]
Caused Plundering of People	true	[1]
Caused Swindling of People	true	[1]
Length Range in Miles	2-3	[1]
Currency	pounds sterling	[1]
Cost Amount Approximate	100000	[1]
Passed by	House	[1]
Caused	Swindling of People	[1]
Resulted From	Valley Railway Construction	[1]
Required Station	true	[1]
Described As Scandalous Job	true	[1]
People Plundered by	true	[1]
People Swindled by	true	[1]
Cost Amount	100000	[1]
Described As	cursed	[1]
Rdfs:label	Valley railway	[1]
To Be Constructed Sooner or Later	null	[3]
Was Made by	Opposition	[1]
Was Work of	Opposition	[1]

Timeline axis is valid_time — when each source says the fact was true in the world, not when Dontopedia learned about it. Retracted rows are kept for provenance; coloured stripes indicate the context kind.

51 undated

—

asItHadBeenMadedocument/01203ffc-4446-4e9f-9b21-65587067f0df

true

—

beingHurriedtrove-cooktown/storekeeper-cooktown

null

—

causeddocument/01203ffc-4446-4e9f-9b21-65587067f0df

ex:swindling-of-people

—

causedPlunderingOfPeopledocument/01203ffc-4446-4e9f-9b21-65587067f0df

true

—

causedSwindlingOfPeopledocument/01203ffc-4446-4e9f-9b21-65587067f0df

true

—

costdocument/01203ffc-4446-4e9f-9b21-65587067f0df

110000

—

cost110000document/01203ffc-4446-4e9f-9b21-65587067f0df

110000

—

costAmountdocument/01203ffc-4446-4e9f-9b21-65587067f0df

100000

—

costAmountApproximatedocument/01203ffc-4446-4e9f-9b21-65587067f0df

100000

—

currencydocument/01203ffc-4446-4e9f-9b21-65587067f0df

pounds sterling

—

dependentOnRegulationtrove-cooktown/prostitution

ex:traffic-regulation

—

describedAsdocument/01203ffc-4446-4e9f-9b21-65587067f0df

cursed

—

describedAsScandalousJobdocument/01203ffc-4446-4e9f-9b21-65587067f0df

true

—

discussedOpeningTotrove-cooktown/malay-cooktown

ex:creek-street

—

financiallyRiskyNowtrove-cooktown/prostitution

null

—

fundingVotedtrove-cooktown/coloured-persons

80000

—

fundingVotedtrove-cooktown/coloured-persons

80000

—

hadToBePerfectedByHavingStationSuitableToItdocument/01203ffc-4446-4e9f-9b21-65587067f0df

true

—

halfMillionCosttrove-cooktown/storekeeper-cooktown

null

—

involvestrove-cooktown/storekeeper-cooktown

half-a-million of money

—

involvesCostOftrove-cooktown/storekeeper-cooktown

£320,000

—

lengthdocument/01203ffc-4446-4e9f-9b21-65587067f0df

two or three miles

—

lengthInMilesdocument/01203ffc-4446-4e9f-9b21-65587067f0df

—

lengthInMilesdocument/01203ffc-4446-4e9f-9b21-65587067f0df

—

lengthRangeInMilesdocument/01203ffc-4446-4e9f-9b21-65587067f0df

2-3

—

lengthTwoOrThreeMilesdocument/01203ffc-4446-4e9f-9b21-65587067f0df

two or three miles

—

nicknameddocument/01203ffc-4446-4e9f-9b21-65587067f0df

cursed Valley railway

—

openingDiscussedtrove-cooktown/prostitution

ex:creek-street

—

oughtNeverToHaveBeenMadedocument/01203ffc-4446-4e9f-9b21-65587067f0df

true

—

passedBydocument/01203ffc-4446-4e9f-9b21-65587067f0df

ex:house

—

peopleHadBeenSwindledAndPlundereddocument/01203ffc-4446-4e9f-9b21-65587067f0df

true

—

peoplePlunderedBydocument/01203ffc-4446-4e9f-9b21-65587067f0df

true

—

peopleSwindledBydocument/01203ffc-4446-4e9f-9b21-65587067f0df

true

—

peopleWerePlundereddocument/01203ffc-4446-4e9f-9b21-65587067f0df

true

—

peopleWereSwindleddocument/01203ffc-4446-4e9f-9b21-65587067f0df

true

—

proposedRouteThroughtrove-cooktown/coloured-persons

ex:center-of-valley-to-bulimba

—

railwaySpeculationtrove-cooktown/prostitution

null

—

labeldocument/01203ffc-4446-4e9f-9b21-65587067f0df

Valley railway

—

typedocument/01203ffc-4446-4e9f-9b21-65587067f0df

ex:Infrastructure

—

typedocument/01203ffc-4446-4e9f-9b21-65587067f0df

ex:Railway

—

reportOftrove-cooktown/storekeeper-cooktown

ex:select-committee

—

requiredStationdocument/01203ffc-4446-4e9f-9b21-65587067f0df

true

—

resultedFromdocument/01203ffc-4446-4e9f-9b21-65587067f0df

ex:valley-railway-construction

—

shouldBeForThemToDivideShameAndBlamedocument/01203ffc-4446-4e9f-9b21-65587067f0df

true

—

shouldBeOntrove-cooktown/prostitution

ex:that-line

—

toBeConstructedSoonerOrLatertrove-cooktown/prostitution

null

—

wasEntirelyWorkOfPresentOppositiondocument/01203ffc-4446-4e9f-9b21-65587067f0df

true

—

wasMadeBydocument/01203ffc-4446-4e9f-9b21-65587067f0df

ex:opposition

—

wasScandalousdocument/01203ffc-4446-4e9f-9b21-65587067f0df

true

—

wasWorkOfdocument/01203ffc-4446-4e9f-9b21-65587067f0df

ex:opposition

—

workOfdocument/01203ffc-4446-4e9f-9b21-65587067f0df

ex:present-opposition

References (5)

5 references

[1]PARLIAMENT. MONDAY, SEPTEMBER 16. LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBL.36 facts
trove.nla.gov.aucustomctx:claims/document/01203ffc-4446-4e9f-9b21-65587067f0df
- full textPARLIAMENT. MONDAY, SEPTEMBER 16. LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBL.
  text/plain50 KBtrove:article/3501421
  Show excerpt
  17 Sep 1889 - PARLIAMENT. Brisbane Courier (Qld. : 1864 - 1933), Tuesday 17 September 1889, page 6 PARLIAMENT. MONDAY, SEI-TEHIHE« IG. LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBL. The SPEAKER (Hon. A. A orton) took the chair at 3 30 o'clock, and read prayers. KESI…
[2]Storekeeper Cooktown5 facts
customctx:genes/trove-cooktown/storekeeper-cooktown
[3]Prostitution6 facts
customctx:genes/trove-cooktown/prostitution
[4]Malay Cooktown1 fact
customctx:genes/trove-cooktown/malay-cooktown
[5]Coloured Persons3 facts
customctx:genes/trove-cooktown/coloured-persons

Keep researching

Missing something or suspicious of what's here? Kick off a research session — a Claude agent will investigate, cite its sources, and file new facts into a dedicated context you can review before accepting into the shared view.

Valley Railway

Length in Milesin disputelengthInMiles

Rdf:typein disputerdf:type

Dependent on RegulationdependentOnRegulation

Opening DiscussedopeningDiscussed

Being HurriedbeingHurried

Half Million CosthalfMillionCost

Involvesinvolves

Involves Cost ofinvolvesCostOf

Report ofreportOf

Discussed Opening todiscussedOpeningTo

Funding VotedfundingVoted

Proposed Route ThroughproposedRouteThrough

Inbound mentions (17)

associatedWithAssociated With(2)

lackedActionOnLacked Action on(2)

accessibleByAccessible by(1)

causedByCaused by(1)

criticizesCarelessnessCriticizes Carelessness(1)

determinedToAchieveDetermined to Achieve(1)

passedPassed(1)

passedJobsLikePassed Jobs Like(1)

plunderedByPlundered by(1)

presupposesNeedForPresupposes Need for(1)

producedProduced(1)

promisedToOpenPromised to Open(1)

publiclyExpressedViewOnPlatformAboutPublicly Expressed View on Platform About(1)

resultedInResulted in(1)

swindledBySwindled by(1)

Other facts (36)

Timeline

References (5)

See also

Keep researching

Length in Milesin dispute`lengthInMiles`

Rdf:typein dispute`rdf:type`

Dependent on Regulation`dependentOnRegulation`

Opening Discussed`openingDiscussed`

Being Hurried`beingHurried`

Half Million Cost`halfMillionCost`

Involves`involves`

Involves Cost of`involvesCostOf`

Report of`reportOf`

Discussed Opening to`discussedOpeningTo`

Funding Voted`fundingVoted`

Proposed Route Through`proposedRouteThrough`

`associatedWith`Associated With(2)

`lackedActionOn`Lacked Action on(2)

`accessibleBy`Accessible by(1)

`causedBy`Caused by(1)

`criticizesCarelessness`Criticizes Carelessness(1)

`determinedToAchieve`Determined to Achieve(1)

`passed`Passed(1)

`passedJobsLike`Passed Jobs Like(1)

`plunderedBy`Plundered by(1)

`presupposesNeedFor`Presupposes Need for(1)

`produced`Produced(1)

`promisedToOpen`Promised to Open(1)

`publiclyExpressedViewOnPlatformAbout`Publicly Expressed View on Platform About(1)

`resultedIn`Resulted in(1)

`swindledBy`Swindled by(1)