context
Direct P2
ctx:genes/discrepancy/direct-p2No external document is attached to this context. (Many contexts are pure organisational labels.)
Facts in this context
Grouped by subject. Each subject links to its full article.
Rosie Hippie9 factsex:rosie-hippie
| aliveThrough | 1949+ |
| bornIn | Mareeba |
| doesNotConnectTo | Davis Line |
| hasNoneChildren | true |
| hasSignificantDifferentiators | born Mareeba and None for children |
| hasWellDocumentedAliasChain | Homalee/Homarlee/Honalle/Hippie/Epi |
| husband | Willie Api |
| marriedTo | Willie Api |
| marriedTo | Paddy Julian |
Removals 1916 Source8 factsex:removals-1916-source
| daughtersAged | 8 and 5 |
| fromLocation | Port Douglas |
| hasInformant | Government officials |
| hasProximity | Contemporary administrative action |
| hasPurpose | Removal administration |
| hasTextTier | Tier 1 |
| notesDaughtersOf | Rosie Deceased |
| toLocation | Yarrabah |
Julia7 factsex:julia
| bornApprox | 1894 |
| bornApprox | 1896 |
| bornAt | Romeo |
| near | Cooktown Bloomfield Corridor |
| orphanedAndSentTo | Yarrabah |
| remainAs | Possible Collateral in the tree |
| sentFrom | Rossville |
Yarrabah Marriage Record 19127 factsex:yarrabah-marriage-record-1912
| date | 1912-02-15 |
| doesNotGiveGivenNameForFather | true |
| givesFather | Davis |
| givesMother | Rosie Rosie |
| isStrongPrimaryEvidence | true |
| namesFatherDavis | true |
| noDirectRecordLinks | Julia to George Davis Rosie |
Chief Protector Report 1905 Source6 factsex:chief-protector-report-1905-source
| hasInformant | Northern Protector of Aboriginals |
| hasProximity | Contemporary official report |
| hasPurpose | Annual government reporting |
| hasTextTier | Tier 1 |
| listsJuliaAndNellieAs | orphans |
| originatesFrom | Rossville |
Indigence File 1942 Rosie Hippie Source6 factsex:indigence-file-1942-rosie-hippie-source
| forPerson | Rosie Hippie |
| hasInformant | Police and applicant |
| hasProximity | Created at time of application |
| hasPurpose | Welfare administration |
| hasTextTier | Tier 1 |
| statesAgeApprox | 73 |
Daughters 19165 factsex:daughters-1916
| aged | 8 and 5 |
| bornApprox | 1911 |
| bornApprox | 1908 |
| materiallyYoungerThan | Nellie |
| materiallyYoungerThan | Julia |
Indigence File 1942 Rosie Hippie5 factsex:indigence-file-1942-rosie-hippie
| contradicts | Chief Protector Report 1901 |
| listsChildren | None |
| namesBrother | Tommy Gray |
| pushesToward | Different Kin Network |
| statesBornIn | Mareeba |
Marriage Exemption Register 1949 Source5 factsex:marriage-exemption-register-1949-source
| hasInformant | Government registrar |
| hasProximity | Created at time of marriage |
| hasPurpose | Legal marriage record |
| hasTextTier | Tier 1 |
| names | Rosie Julian nee Rosie Hippi |
Analysis Section 44 factsex:analysis-section-4
| posesQuestion | one, two, or three different women named Rosie |
| statesNotSimpleTwoSourceConflict | true |
| stronglySuggests | 1916 Port Douglas Rosie Is Different Woman |
| suggestsAlternative | Rosie 1916 Had Second Set Children Later |
Fred Leftwich Oral History Source4 factsex:fred-leftwich-oral-history-source
| hasInformant | Julia's son |
| hasProximity | Recorded decades after events |
| hasPurpose | Published oral history |
| hasTextTier | Tier 2 |
Ged Death Year 1904 Source4 factsex:ged-death-year-1904-source
| hasInformant | Unknown tree compiler |
| hasProximity | Unknown provenance |
| hasPurpose | Personal tree |
| hasTextTier | Tier 3 |
Julia Leftwich Death Index 1986 Source4 factsex:julia-leftwich-death-index-1986-source
| hasInformant | Late-life informant (likely a child) |
| hasProximity | Created at time of death |
| hasPurpose | Death registration |
| hasTextTier | Tier 1 |
Next Steps Section 44 factsex:next-steps-section-4
| recommendsInvestigate | 1906 Brackenridge Birth Registrations |
| recommendsOrder | 1916 Port Douglas Death Record |
| recommendsSearchFor | Death Record 1903 1905 Rosie |
| toSeeIfNames | surname or husband |
Next Steps Section 54 factsex:next-steps-section-5
| recommendsOrder | Julia Leftwich Death Certificate |
| recommendsOrder | Full Yarrabah Marriage Certificate |
| toCheck | whether it names biological parents alongside the foster parent |
| toSeeIfContains | more detail on the father |
Port Douglas Hospital Death Record 1916 Source4 factsex:port-douglas-hospital-death-record-1916-source
| hasInformant | Hospital/registrar |
| hasProximity | Created at the time of death |
| hasPurpose | Death record |
| hasTextTier | Tier 1 |
Reaching Back Oral History Source4 factsex:reaching-back-oral-history-source
| hasInformant | Julia herself, in old age |
| hasProximity | Recorded decades after events |
| hasPurpose | Published oral history |
| hasTextTier | Tier 2 |
Text4 factsex:text
| assumesMultipleRosiesExist | |
| genreIs | genealogical conflict analysis |
| referencesHartleyOralHistory | |
| valuesTier1ContemporaryRecordsOverGED |
Yarrabah Marriage Record 1912 Source4 factsex:yarrabah-marriage-record-1912-source
| hasInformant | Julia herself or mission administrator |
| hasProximity | Created at time of marriage |
| hasPurpose | Marriage registration |
| hasTextTier | Tier 1 (transcription of primary register) |
Chief Protector Report 19013 factsex:chief-protector-report-1901
| statesRosie | legally married to a kanaka at Mossman |
| statesRosieHad | 3+ children at Yarrabah |
| strongFitFor | Rosie Hippie |
Port Douglas 1916 Death Claim3 factsex:port-douglas-1916-death-claim
| concerns | Rosie Port Douglas 1916 |
| recordsDeathDate | 1916-03-17 |
| recordsLocation | Port Douglas Hospital |
Rosie Hippie 1949 Alive Claim3 factsex:rosie-hippie-1949-alive-claim
| concerns | Rosie Hippie |
| recordsMarriageDate | 1949-05-13 |
| showsAliveThrough | 1949 |
Three Incompatible Claims3 factsex:three-incompatible-claims
| includesClaimA | Ged 1904 Death Claim |
| includesClaimB | Port Douglas 1916 Death Claim |
| includesClaimC | Rosie Hippie 1949 Alive Claim |
Chief Protector Report 19052 factsex:chief-protector-report-1905
| alignsLooselyWith | Ged 1904 Death Date |
| isConsistentWith | Mothers Death Before 1905 |
Connection to George Davis Rosie2 factsex:connection-to-george-davis-rosie
| geographicallyCoherent | Cooktown Bloomfield Corridor |
| isInferential | true |
Ged 1904 Death Claim2 factsex:ged-1904-death-claim
| concerns | Rosie Main |
| givesDeathYear | 1904 |
Ged Date 19042 factsex:ged-date-1904
| directionallyConsistent | Orphan 1905 |
| isUnverified | true |
Julia Leftwich Death Index 19862 factsex:julia-leftwich-death-index-1986
| givesFather | - Nunn |
| reference | 1986/52864 |
Julia Own Later Account2 factsex:julia-own-later-account
| explainsNunnAs | foster surname taken after her mother's death |
| isTier2 | true |
Nellie2 factsex:nellie
| bornApprox | 1901 |
| bornApprox | 1900 |
Proof2 factsex:proof
| requires | Record Names Julia Child George Davis Rosie |
| requires | Record Full Name George Davis |
Resolution Section 42 factsex:resolution-section-4
| is | UNRESOLVED |
| pointsToward | At Least Two Possibly Three Distinct Women |
Resolution Section 52 factsex:resolution-section-5
| is | UNRESOLVED |
| upgradedTo | PROBABLE |
Rosie Mother Julia Nellie2 factsex:rosie-mother-julia-nellie
| given | Orphan Designation 1905 |
| likelyDiedBefore | 1905 |
Rosie Port Douglas 19162 factsex:rosie-port-douglas-1916
| hasRealTier1DeathRecord | true |
| shouldBeKeptAs | Separate Thread |
Tree2 factsex:tree
| doNotMergeWithout | Record Naming Shared Children or Explicit Identification |
| shouldPreserveAs | Separate Identity Threads |
Willie Api2 factsex:willie-api
| locatedAt | Mossman |
| was | South Sea Islander |
1906 Brackenridge Birth Registrations1 factex:1906-brackenridge-birth-registrations
| nameMother | Rosie |
1986 Death Index1 factex:1986-death-index
| reflects | Foster Identity Not Biological |
Analysis1 factex:analysis
| hedgesWithLikelyUnverifiedPossibly |
Analysis Section 51 factex:analysis-section-5
| names1912MarriageRecordAs | strongest single piece of evidence |
Chronological Fit1 factex:chronological-fit
| compelling | true |
Daughters 8 and 51 factex:daughters-8-and-5
| cannotBe | Julia and Nellie |
Davis1 factex:davis
| isCommonSurname | true |
Death Record 1903 1905 Rosie1 factex:death-record-1903-1905-rosie
| inLocation | Cooktown Rossville Bloomfield Corridor |
Different Kin Network1 factex:different-kin-network
| differsFrom | Cooktown Rossville Mother |
Evidence1 factex:evidence
| prioritizesPrimaryTier1 |
Fred Leftwich Oral History1 factex:fred-leftwich-oral-history
| says | Nellie Watkins was Julia's sister |
Full Yarrabah Marriage Certificate1 factex:full-yarrabah-marriage-certificate
| reference | 2010/N/4576 |
Ged Date1 factex:ged-date
| hasNoProvenance | true |
Geographic Fit1 factex:geographic-fit
| matches | Hartley Oral History Edgar Mother Cooktown |
Julia Born 18941 factex:julia-born-1894
| before | Edgar Children With Caroline 1910 |
Julia Leftwich Death Certificate1 factex:julia-leftwich-death-certificate
| reference | 1986/52864 |
Parental Link1 factex:parental-link
| preserveExactlyAsRecorded | father Davis, mother Rosie Rosie |
Port Douglas Hospital Death Record 19161 factex:port-douglas-hospital-death-record-1916
| isGenuineTier1Record | true |
Reaching Back Oral History1 factex:reaching-back-oral-history
| juliaSays | Nunn family looked after her after her mother died |
Resolution1 factex:resolution
| framesAsUnresolvedProbable |
Rosie1 factex:rosie
| isCommonGivenName | true |
Rosie Hippie Thread1 factex:rosie-hippie-thread
| isMostDocumentedOfThree | true |
Rosie Name1 factex:rosie-name
| commonIn | North Queensland Mission Records |
Section 4 Rosie Death Year1 factex:section-4-rosie-death-year
| presentsConflict | Three Incompatible Claims |
Section 5 Julia Nunn1 factex:section-5-julia-nunn
| presentsConflict | Julia Connection Conflict |
Tommy Gray1 factex:tommy-gray
| locatedAt | Mona Mona |
Tree Building1 factex:tree-building
| avoidsPrematureMerging |