context
Direct P3
ctx:genes/discrepancy/direct-p3No external document is attached to this context. (Many contexts are pure organisational labels.)
Facts in this context
Grouped by subject. Each subject links to its full article.
George Edgar Davis Mossman8 factsex:george-edgar-davis-mossman
| adultStatusIn1930s | adult |
| familySizeDescription | large family |
| hasLargeFamily | true |
| isAdultIn1930s | true |
| isOlder | Edgar Davis Mona Mona Young |
| maritalStatus | married |
| noIndicationOfBlindness | Blindness |
| occupation | labourer |
Sibling Group 19217 factsex:sibling-group-1921
| includes | Kathleen Davis Age2 5 1921 |
| includes | Pansy Davis |
| includes | Hazel Davis |
| includes | Edgar Davis Age5 1921 |
| removalYear | 1921 |
| removedFrom | Edmonton |
| removedTo | Mona Mona |
1921 Removals Register5 factsex:1921-removals-register
| describesRemovalOf | Edgar Davis Age5 1921 |
| informant | Government officials |
| proximity | Contemporary administrative record |
| purpose | Removal administration |
| tier | Tier 1 |
1932 Cilento Survey5 factsex:1932-cilento-survey
| informant | Dr Cilento's inspection team |
| mentions | Edgar Davis Cairns Blind |
| proximity | Contemporary medical survey |
| purpose | Medical/institutional census |
| tier | Tier 1 |
Julia Leftwich5 factsex:julia-leftwich
| alsoKnownAs | Julia |
| birthYearApprox | ~1894-1896 |
| enteredDormitoryLater | Yarrabah |
| marriageYear | 1912 |
| selfReportedAgeAtRemoval | about 16 |
1938 Exemption Card4 factsex:1938-exemption-card
| alignsWith | Itm3825162 |
| fullName | Edgar Leonard Davis |
| location | Mossman |
| parentsStatus | H/C H/C |
Card Index 33 32354 factsex:card-index-33-3235
| category | Sickness |
| code | 33/3235 |
| location | Mona Mona |
| name | Edgar Davis |
Card Index 34 11994 factsex:card-index-34-1199
| category | Removals |
| code | 34/1199 |
| location | Mossman |
| name | Edgar Davis |
Card Index 38 11074 factsex:card-index-38-1107
| category | Exemptions |
| code | 38/1107 |
| location | Mossman |
| name | Edgar Davis |
Reaching Back Oral History4 factsex:reaching-back-oral-history
| informant | Julia herself, in old age |
| proximity | Recorded decades after the event |
| purpose | Published oral history |
| tier | Tier 2 |
1905 Chief Protector Report3 factsex:1905-chief-protector-report
| informant | Northern Protector |
| purpose | Annual government reporting; age was an official field |
| tier | Tier 1 |
1905 Protector Report3 factsex:1905-protector-report
| locationOfRemoval | Rossville |
| recordsAge | 9 |
| status | H/C |
Chief Protector Card Index Entry Mona Mona 19333 factsex:chief-protector-card-index-entry-mona-mona-1933
| category | Sickness |
| location | Mona Mona |
| year | 1933 |
Chief Protector Card Index Entry Mossman 19343 factsex:chief-protector-card-index-entry-mossman-1934
| category | Removals |
| location | Mossman |
| year | 1934 |
Chief Protector Card Index Entry Mossman 19383 factsex:chief-protector-card-index-entry-mossman-1938
| category | Exemptions |
| location | Mossman |
| year | 1938 |
Edgar Davis Age5 19213 factsex:edgar-davis-age5-1921
| ageAtRemoval | 5 |
| consistentWith | Boys School Placement |
| projectedAgeIn1932 | 16 |
Edgar Davis Cairns Blind3 factsex:edgar-davis-cairns-blind
| causeOfBlindness | finger cherry |
| locatedAt | Mona Mona Boys School |
| origin | Cairns |
1907 Industrial School List2 factsex:1907-industrial-school-list
| committedYear | 1906 |
| givesAge | 8 |
1933 Home Secretary Extracts2 factsex:1933-home-secretary-extracts
| content | Edgar Davis - Mona Mona. Instruction at blind school |
| tier | Tier 1 |
Chief Protector Card Index2 factsex:chief-protector-card-index
| hasEntryFor | Edgar Davis |
| usedFor | correspondence tracking |
Chief Protector Card Index Entry Undetailed 19362 factsex:chief-protector-card-index-entry-undetailed-1936
| category | Removals |
| year | 1936 |
Itm38251622 factsex:itm3825162
| location | Mossman |
| title | Exemptions D-J - DAVIS, Edgar Leonard |
Records2 factsex:records
| assumeExistenceOf | Edgar Davis Entities |
| commitToExistenceOf | Julia Leftwich As Child 1905 |
Resolution Section62 factsex:resolution-section6
| status | RESOLVED |
| supportedBy | anti-merge strongly supported |
Text2 factsex:text
| framesOralHistoryAsLessReliable | Late Life Recollection |
| performsResolution | Edgar Davis Conflict |
1905 Official Report1 factex:1905-official-report
| preferredForAge | Julia Leftwich Removal Age |
1905 Report1 factex:1905-report
| isContemporary | Event Time |
1906 Baptism Age1 factex:1906-baptism-age
| consistentWith | 1905 Report Age9 |
1906 Yarrabah Baptism1 factex:1906-yarrabah-baptism
| givesAge | about 11 years old |
1907 School List1 factex:1907-school-list
| slightlyInconsistent | Other Records |
1933 1934 Home Secretary Extracts1 factex:1933-1934-home-secretary-extracts
| describeSubjectAs | blind |
1933 Mona Mona Sickness Card1 factex:1933-mona-mona-sickness-card
| belongsTo | Blind Edgar Davis Edmonton Mona Mona |
1934 1199 Removals Mossman1 factex:1934-1199-removals-mossman
| belongsTo | George Edgar Davis Mossman |
1934 Blind Card1 factex:1934-blind-card
| belongsTo | Blind Edgar Davis Edmonton Mona Mona |
1934 Home Secretary Extracts1 factex:1934-home-secretary-extracts
| content | E Davis - Blind. Pass to return to Mona Mona |
1936 3096 Removals1 factex:1936-3096-removals
| belongsTo | George Edgar Davis Mossman |
1938 1107 Exemptions Mossman1 factex:1938-1107-exemptions-mossman
| belongsTo | George Edgar Davis Mossman |
33 3235 Card1 factex:33-3235-card
| shouldNotIncludeIn | Direct Line Edgar Trail |
Ages in Reports1 factex:ages-in-reports
| frequentlyImprecise | Aboriginal Protection Reports |
All Sources Section61 factex:all-sources-section6
| areTier1 | Tier 1 Sources |
Analysis Section61 factex:analysis-section6
| dependsOn | Same Person Question 1933 1934 |
Analysis Section71 factex:analysis-section7
| prefersTier1OverTier2 |
Author1 factex:author
| believes1905ReportAccurate | Julia Age at Removal |
Author Section61 factex:author-section6
| assertsResolution | Two Edgar Davises Distinction |
Blind Edgar Davis Edmonton Mona Mona1 factex:blind-edgar-davis-edmonton-mona-mona
| isYounger | Blind Edgar Davis Edmonton Mona Mona |
Dormitory Entry1 factex:dormitory-entry
| possiblyAtAge16Around1912 | Julia Leftwich |
Evidence Section61 factex:evidence-section6
| isStrong | Two Different Edgar Davises |
Family Tree Notes1 factex:family-tree-notes
| observes | dormitory placement and first arrival at Yarrabah may not have been the same event |
Four Independent Tier1 Records1 factex:four-independent-tier1-records
| consistentlyDescribe | Blind Child Young Man Edgar Davis Mona Mona |
Historical Context1 factex:historical-context
| involvesAboriginalProtection | Early 20th Century Australia |
Julia Birth Year1 factex:julia-birth-year
| consistentWithMultipleRecords | 1905 Report 1906 Baptism 1912 Marriage |
Julia Recollection1 factex:julia-recollection
| givenDecadesLater | Old Age |
Kathleen Davis Age2 5 19211 factex:kathleen-davis-age2-5-1921
| ageAtRemoval | 2.5 |
Oral History Age161 factex:oral-history-age16
| refersToDifferentMilestone | dormitory entry or another significant event |
Protection Era Records1 factex:protection-era-records
| exhibitAgeDrift | normal drift |
Reaching Back1 factex:reaching-back
| containsAccountBy | Julia Leftwich |
Resolution Section71 factex:resolution-section7
| status | RESOLVED |
Section 61 factex:section-6
| hasTitle | Edgar Davis Identity: Direct Line vs Mona Mona Child |
Section 6 Analysis1 factex:section-6-analysis
| favors | two different people |
Section 71 factex:section-7
| hasTitle | Julia Leftwich / Julia 1905 Removal: Age at Removal |
Text Section61 factex:text-section6
| expressesConflict | Edgar Davis Identity Conflict |
Text Section71 factex:text-section7
| expressesConflict | Julia Age Conflict |