context
Direct P4
ctx:genes/discrepancy/direct-p4No external document is attached to this context. (Many contexts are pure organisational labels.)
Facts in this context
Grouped by subject. Each subject links to its full article.
1905 Protector Report8 factsex:1905-protector-report
| classifiesBothAs | Orphans |
| doesNotEstablish | Sibling Relationship Julia Nellie |
| doesNotName | Parents |
| hasProximity | Contemporary |
| hasPurpose | Official removal report |
| hasTierInTable | Tier 1 |
| recordsAgeOfJulia | 9 |
| recordsAgeOfNellie | 4.5 |
1906 Yarrabah Baptism7 factsex:1906-yarrabah-baptism
| hasProximity | Near-contemporary |
| hasPurpose | Baptism record |
| hasTierInTable | Tier 1 |
| namesNo | Parents |
| providesSupportingEvidenceFor | Sibling Link |
| recordsAgeApproxOfJulia | 11 |
| recordsAgeApproxOfNellie | 9 |
Tindale Index7 factsex:tindale-index
| derivesFrom | Tindale Fieldwork |
| hasProximity | Compiled index |
| hasPurpose | Anthropological research |
| hasTierInTable | Tier 2 |
| lists | Watkins Nellie |
| lists | Watkins Julia |
| listsBoth | Watkins Julia and Nellie |
1923 Yarrabah Baptism6 factsex:1923-yarrabah-baptism
| establishesIdentityLinkAs | clean Tier 1 |
| forChild | Alexander Watson |
| givesMotherAs | Nellie Murgha Nee Watkin |
| hasProximity | Contemporary |
| hasPurpose | Baptism record |
| hasTierInTable | Tier 1 |
Fred Leftwich Oral History6 factsex:fred-leftwich-oral-history
| hasPage | 78 |
| hasProximity | Decades later |
| hasPurpose | Published oral history |
| hasTierInTable | Tier 2 |
| publishedIn | Reaching Back |
| references | Reaching Back P78 |
Port Douglas Nellie6 factsex:port-douglas-nellie
| isAlmostCertainly | Different Older Nellie |
| isNot | Julia Sister Nellie |
| isStrongAntiMergeFor | 1905 Rossville Nellie |
| married | Fred Suckamoos |
| ranAwayFrom | Yarrabah |
| wasLivingWith | Suckamoos |
1907 Marriage Application Correspondence4 factsex:1907-marriage-application-correspondence
| describesNellieOf | Port Douglas |
| hasProximity | Contemporary |
| hasPurpose | Marriage permission administration |
| hasTierInTable | Tier 1 |
Fred Leftwich3 factsex:fred-leftwich
| givesJuliaSisterAs | Nellie Watkins |
| isSonOf | Julia Watkins |
| saysNellieWatkinsWas | Julia Watkins Sister |
Julia Watkins3 factsex:julia-watkins
| baptisedIn | 1906 Yarrabah Baptism |
| fromLocationIn1905 | Rossville |
| sentToIn1905 | Yarrabah |
Nellie Watkins3 factsex:nellie-watkins
| baptisedIn | 1906 Yarrabah Baptism |
| fromLocationIn1905 | Rossville |
| sentToIn1905 | Yarrabah |
Julia Nellie Watkins in Tindale2 factsex:julia-nellie-watkins-in-tindale
| hasTitle | 11. Julia / Nellie Watkins in Tindale |
| isSupportingEvidenceFor | Discrepancy 8 |
Julia Nellie Yarrabah Baptism Pair2 factsex:julia-nellie-yarrabah-baptism-pair
| hasTitle | 9. Julia / Nellie Yarrabah Baptism Pair |
| isSubComponentOf | Discrepancy 8 |
Mission Registrar2 factsex:mission-registrar
| isInformantOf | 1906 Yarrabah Baptism |
| isInformantOf | 1923 Yarrabah Baptism |
Sibling Link2 factsex:sibling-link
| shouldBeNotedAs | Inference Based Not Certificate Proved |
| treatedAs | Established for Working Purposes |
Strict Framework Reading2 factsex:strict-framework-reading
| appliesTo | Siblingship Establishment |
| requires | Parent Naming Record |
Age 7 in 19071 factex:age-7-in-1907
| isFarTooYoungFor | Marriage Case |
Age Differential1 factex:age-differential
| makesMerge | Implausible |
Age Discrepancy Julia1 factex:age-discrepancy-julia
| involvesShiftFrom | 9 |
Age Discrepancy Nellie1 factex:age-discrepancy-nellie
| involvesShiftFrom | 4.5 |
Analysis Section 101 factex:analysis-section-10
| calculatesAgeIn1907As | about 7 |
Analysis Section 121 factex:analysis-section-12
| claims1923Baptism | Explicitly Bridges Watkin Murgha |
Analysis Section 81 factex:analysis-section-8
| claimsHas | Multiple Independent Lines of Evidence |
Anti Merge1 factex:anti-merge
| shouldBePreservedAs | Control |
Baptism Registrar1 factex:baptism-registrar
| mayHaveEstimatedAges | Independently |
Evidence Convergence1 factex:evidence-convergence
| overridesStrictRequirement | For Working Purposes |
Evidence Line a1 factex:evidence-line-a
| consistsOfCoRemoval | Same Place Same Time Orphans |
Evidence Line B1 factex:evidence-line-b
| consistsOfJointBaptism | Yarrabah Baptism |
Evidence Line C1 factex:evidence-line-c
| consistsOfTindaleIndexing | Watkins Surname at Yarrabah |
Evidence Line D1 factex:evidence-line-d
| consistsOfExplicitNaming | Fred Leftwich Claim |
Four Sources1 factex:four-sources
| convergeOn | Same Conclusion |
Framework1 factex:framework
| presupposesRequirementOf | Parent Naming for Siblingship |
Julia Branch Nellie1 factex:julia-branch-nellie
| hasAgeIn1905 | 4.5 |
Julia Nellie Sibling Link1 factex:julia-nellie-sibling-link
| hasTitle | 8. Julia / Nellie Sibling Link |
Julia Sister Identity1 factex:julia-sister-identity
| resolvesAs | UNRESOLVED |
Mission Era Ages1 factex:mission-era-ages
| areFrequently | Estimated and Inconsistent |
Mission Era Records1 factex:mission-era-records
| implicatesFrequent | Age Estimation Errors |
Multiple Independent Lines of Evidence1 factex:multiple-independent-lines-of-evidence
| supports | Sibling Identification Julia Nellie |
Nellie Age Discrepancy1 factex:nellie-age-discrepancy
| significantEnoughTo | Note But Not Break Sibling Id |
Nellie Age Shift1 factex:nellie-age-shift
| isInconsistent | One Year Change |
Nellie Murgha1 factex:nellie-murgha
| wasFormerly | Nellie Watkin |
Nellie Watkin Murgha1 factex:nellie-watkin-murgha
| isSameAsRememberedBy | Fred Leftwich Julia Sister |
Nellie Watkin Murgha As Julia Sister1 factex:nellie-watkin-murgha-as-julia-sister
| isMostProbable | Interpretation |
Nellie Watkins Nellie Murgha Surname Transition1 factex:nellie-watkins-nellie-murgha-surname-transition
| hasTitle | 12. Nellie Watkins / Nellie Murgha Surname Transition |
Northern Protector1 factex:northern-protector
| isInformantOf | 1905 Protector Report |
No Single Record1 factex:no-single-record
| explicitlyNamesBothAs | Children Same Parents |
No Source1 factex:no-source
| contradicts | Sibling Link |
Port Douglas Nellie Nellie Watkins Identity1 factex:port-douglas-nellie-nellie-watkins-identity
| hasTitle | 10. Port Douglas Nellie / Nellie Watkins Identity |
Resolutions1 factex:resolutions
| performSpeechActOf | Closing Discrepancies |
Resolution Section 101 factex:resolution-section-10
| resolvesAs | RESOLVED |
Resolution Section 111 factex:resolution-section-11
| resolvesAs | RESOLVED as supporting evidence |
Resolution Section 121 factex:resolution-section-12
| resolvesNameBridgeAs | RESOLVED |
Resolution Section 81 factex:resolution-section-8
| resolvesAs | HIGHLY PROBABLE |
Resolution Section 91 factex:resolution-section-9
| resolvesAgeQuestionAs | UNRESOLVED |
Text1 factex:text
| usesTableFormatFor | Source Comparison |
Text Author1 factex:text-author
| advocatesSiblingLinkAs | Highly Probable |
Tindale Fieldwork1 factex:tindale-fieldwork
| isInformantOf | Tindale Index |
Tindale Listing1 factex:tindale-listing
| independentlyCorroborates | Shared Surname Community |
Yarrabah Mission1 factex:yarrabah-mission
| contextOfMultipleRecords | Baptisms Removals |