source context

V2 P2

ctx:genes/discrepancy/v2-p2

kind: custommode: permissive154 statements66 distinct subjects

No external document is attached to this context. (Many contexts are pure organisational labels.)

Facts in this context

Grouped by subject. Each subject links to its full article.

1942 Indigence File Rosie Hippie10 facts`ex:1942-indigence-file-rosie-hippie`

contradicts	1901 Report Children Claim
estimatesAge	~73
forPerson	Rosie Hippie
hasInformant	Police and applicant
hasProximity	Created at time of application
hasPurpose	Welfare administration
hasTierInText	Tier 1
listsChildrenAs	None
namesBrother	Tommy Gray
statesBirthPlace	Mareeba

1905 Chief Protector Report7 facts`ex:1905-chief-protector-report`

alignsLooselyWith	Ged 1904 Death Date
consistentWithMothersDeathBefore	1905
hasInformant	Northern Protector of Aboriginals
hasProximity	Contemporary official report
hasPurpose	Annual government reporting
hasTierInText	Tier 1
listsAsOrphans	Julia and Nellie

Julia Leftwich Death Index 19866 facts`ex:julia-leftwich-death-index-1986`

givesFatherAs	- Nunn
hasInformant	Late-life informant (likely a child)
hasProximity	Created at time of death
hasPurpose	Death registration
hasTierInText	Tier 1
reference	1986/52864

Source Table Section 46 facts`ex:source-table-section-4`

listsSource	Ged Death Year 1904 Source
listsSource	1949 Marriage Exemption Register
listsSource	1942 Indigence File Rosie Hippie
listsSource	1916 Removals Record
listsSource	Port Douglas Hospital Death Record 1916
listsSource	1905 Chief Protector Report

1916 Removals Record5 facts`ex:1916-removals-record`

hasInformant	Government officials
hasProximity	Contemporary administrative action
hasPurpose	Removal administration
hasTierInText	Tier 1
notesDaughtersOf	Rosie Deceased 1916

1949 Marriage Exemption Register5 facts`ex:1949-marriage-exemption-register`

hasInformant	Government registrar
hasProximity	Created at time of marriage
hasPurpose	Legal marriage record
hasTierInText	Tier 1
namesPersonAs	Rosie Julian nee Rosie Hippi

Fred Leftwich Oral History5 facts`ex:fred-leftwich-oral-history`

hasInformant	Julias Son
hasProximity	Recorded decades after events
hasPurpose	Published oral history
hasTierInText	Tier 2
saysNellieWatkinsIs	Julia's sister

Port Douglas Hospital Death Record 19165 facts`ex:port-douglas-hospital-death-record-1916`

date	17 Mar 1916
hasInformant	Hospital/registrar
hasProximity	Created at the time of death
hasPurpose	Death record
hasTierInText	Tier 1

Reaching Back Oral History5 facts`ex:reaching-back-oral-history`

hasInformant	Julia Herself in Old Age
hasProximity	Recorded decades after events
hasPurpose	Published oral history
hasTierInText	Tier 2
quotesJuliaSaying	Nunn family looked after her after mother died

Yarrabah Marriage Record 19125 facts`ex:yarrabah-marriage-record-1912`

date	15 Feb 1912
givesFathersName	Davis
givesMothersName	Rosie Rosie
lacksDirectLinkTo	George Davis and Rosie Main Tree
lacksFathersGivenName	True

Ged Death Year 1904 Source4 facts`ex:ged-death-year-1904-source`

hasInformant	Unknown tree compiler
hasProximity	Unknown provenance
hasPurpose	Personal tree
hasTierInText	Tier 3

Julia4 facts`ex:julia`

birthPlaceNear	Cooktown Bloomfield Corridor
bornCirca	~1894
matchesHartleyOralHistory	Edgars Mother From Cooktown
orphanedAndSentTo	Yarrabah From Rossville 1905

Source Table Section 54 facts`ex:source-table-section-5`

listsSource	Reaching Back Oral History
listsSource	Julia Leftwich Death Index 1986
listsSource	Yarrabah Marriage Transcription 1912
listsSource	Fred Leftwich Oral History

Yarrabah Marriage Transcription 19124 facts`ex:yarrabah-marriage-transcription-1912`

hasInformant	Julia herself or mission administrator
hasProximity	Created at time of marriage
hasPurpose	Marriage registration
hasTierInText	Tier 1 (transcription of primary register)

1901 Report3 facts`ex:1901-report`

describesRosieAs	legally married to a kanaka at Mossman
saysRosieHad	3+ children at Yarrabah
strongFitFor	Rosie Hippie

Daughters of 1916 Rosie3 facts`ex:daughters-of-1916-rosie`

bornCirca	~1908 and ~1911
materiallyYoungerThan	Nellie Birth 1900 1901
materiallyYoungerThan	Julia Birth 1894 1896

Julia Davis Link3 facts`ex:julia-davis-link`

hasChronologicalFit	Julia 1894 Before Edgar Children 1910
hasGeographicFit	Cooktown Rossville Hartley Oral History
isCompelling	True

Next Steps Section 43 facts`ex:next-steps-section-4`

includesStepA	Order 1916 Port Douglas Death Record
includesStepB	Search Death 1903 1905 Cooktown
includesStepC	Investigate 1906 Brackenridge Births

Port Douglas Rosie 19163 facts`ex:port-douglas-rosie-1916`

isGenuineTier1Record	Tier 1 Record
isRealTier1DeathRecord	True
suggestsDifferentWomanFrom	Rosie Mother Julia Nellie

Port Douglas Rosie Death 19163 facts`ex:port-douglas-rosie-death-1916`

associatedWith1916Removals	1916 Removals Daughters of Rosie Deceased
deathLocation	Port Douglas Hospital
recordsDeathDate	17 Mar 1916

Rosie Hippie3 facts`ex:rosie-hippie`

hasWellDocumentedAliasChain	True
marriedTo	Willie Api
pushesTowardDifferentKinNetworkThan	Cooktown Rossville Mother Julia Nellie

Rosie Hippie Alive 19493 facts`ex:rosie-hippie-alive-1949`

marriageEvent	Marriage to Paddy Julian 1949
showsAliveThrough	1949
sourceIs	Rosie Hippie Homarlee Epi Thread

Rosie Hippie Homarlee Epi Julian3 facts`ex:rosie-hippie-homarlee-epi-julian`

aliveThrough	1949+
bornIn	Mareeba
marriedToWillieApiThen	Paddy Julian

Three Incompatible Claims About Rosie3 facts`ex:three-incompatible-claims-about-rosie`

includesClaimA	Ged Rosie Death 1904
includesClaimB	Port Douglas Rosie Death 1916
includesClaimC	Rosie Hippie Alive 1949

1906 Brackenridge Birth Registrations2 facts`ex:1906-brackenridge-birth-registrations`

canHelpDistinguish	Which Rosie Brackenridge Mother
nameMother	Rosie

1916 Removals Daughters of Rosie Deceased2 facts`ex:1916-removals-daughters-of-rosie-deceased`

describesDaughtersAges	8 and 5
removalFromTo	Port Douglas to Yarrabah

Ged Rosie Death 19042 facts`ex:ged-rosie-death-1904`

givesDeathYear	1904
sourceIs	Ged

Next Steps Section 52 facts`ex:next-steps-section-5`

includesOrderJuliaDeathCert	1986 52864
includesOrderYarrabahMarriageCert	Reg 2010 N 4576

Rosie Mother Julia Nellie2 facts`ex:rosie-mother-julia-nellie`

isDirectLineCandidate	True
likelyDiedBefore	1905

Section 4 Analysis2 facts`ex:section-4-analysis`

posesQuestion	One Two or Three Different Rosies
statesNotSimpleConflict	not a simple two-source conflict

Section 4 Rosie Rose Death Year2 facts`ex:section-4-rosie-rose-death-year`

describesConflict	Three Incompatible Claims About Rosie
hasTitle	4. Rosie / Rose: Death Year (GED 1904 vs Port Douglas 1916 vs Rosie Hippie alive 1949+)

1912 Marriage Record1 fact`ex:1912-marriage-record`

isStrongPrimaryEvidence

For Davis Rosie Parents

1986 Death Index1 fact`ex:1986-death-index`

reflectsFosterIdentityRatherThanBiological

True

Daughters Aged 8 5 19161 fact`ex:daughters-aged-8-5-1916`

cannotBe

Julia and Nellie

Davis1 fact`ex:davis`

isCommonSurname

True

Do Not Merge Rosies1 fact`ex:do-not-merge-rosies`

withoutRecordThat

Names Shared Children or Explicit Id

Evidence Points Toward1 fact`ex:evidence-points-toward`

indicatesAtLeast

two and possibly three distinct women

Ged 1904 Date1 fact`ex:ged-1904-date`

isUnverifiedButDirectionallyConsistent

With 1905 Orphan

Ged 1904 Death Date1 fact`ex:ged-1904-death-date`

lacksProvenance

Unknown Provenance

Ged Source1 fact`ex:ged-source`

evaluatedAsLowReliability

Tier 3 Unknown Provenance

Julia Davis Rosie Connection1 fact`ex:julia-davis-rosie-connection`

isInferentialButCoherent

Geographically and Chronologically

Julia Death Cert Order1 fact`ex:julia-death-cert-order`

toCheck

biological parents alongside foster

Julia in Tree1 fact`ex:julia-in-tree`

remainAs

Possible Collateral

Julia Nunn1 fact`ex:julia-nunn`

hasMultipleSurnames

Nunn Leftwich Davis

Julia Nunn Later Account1 fact`ex:julia-nunn-later-account`

explainsNunnAs

foster surname after mother's death

Marriage to Paddy Julian 19491 fact`ex:marriage-to-paddy-julian-1949`

date	13 May 1949

Nellie Watkins1 fact`ex:nellie-watkins`

statedAsSisterOf

Julia

Order 1916 Port Douglas Death Record1 fact`ex:order-1916-port-douglas-death-record`

purposeToSee

surname or husband

Parental Link Preservation1 fact`ex:parental-link-preservation`

preserveExactlyAs

father Davis, mother Rosie Rosie

Port Douglas Rosie 1916 Thread1 fact`ex:port-douglas-rosie-1916-thread`

shouldBeKeptSeparateUnless

Joining Record Appears

Proof Requires1 fact`ex:proof-requires`

eitherAOrB

Full Name Record or Julia As Child

Rosie1 fact`ex:rosie`

commonGivenNameIn

North Queensland Mission Records

Rosie Hippie Aliases1 fact`ex:rosie-hippie-aliases`

includesAliases

Homalee/Homarlee/Honalle/Hippie/Epi

Rosie Hippie Homarlee Epi Thread1 fact`ex:rosie-hippie-homarlee-epi-thread`

isMostDocumented

Of the Three Rosies

Rosie Hippie Thread1 fact`ex:rosie-hippie-thread`

doesNotConnectTo

Davis Line

Search Death 1903 1905 Cooktown1 fact`ex:search-death-1903-1905-cooktown`

inWindow

1903-1905

Section 4 Resolution1 fact`ex:section-4-resolution`

statesStatus

UNRESOLVED

Section 5 Analysis1 fact`ex:section-5-analysis`

calls1912MarriageRecord

strongest single piece of evidence

Section 5 Julia Nunn1 fact`ex:section-5-julia-nunn`

describesConflict

Julia Nunn Parentage Conflict

Section 5 Julia Nunn Connection1 fact`ex:section-5-julia-nunn-connection`

hasTitle

5. Julia Nunn: Connection to Davis / Rosie

Section 5 Resolution1 fact`ex:section-5-resolution`

statesStatus

UNRESOLVED, but upgraded to PROBABLE

Text Author1 fact`ex:text-author`

advocatesPreservingSeparateThreads

In Genealogy Tree

Three Rosies Distinct1 fact`ex:three-rosies-distinct`

presupposesMultipleWomenNamedRosie

True

Tier 1 Sources1 fact`ex:tier-1-sources`

preferredOver

Ged Tier 3

Tree Recommendation1 fact`ex:tree-recommendation`

preserveAsSeparateIdentityThreads

Three Rosies

Unresolved Status1 fact`ex:unresolved-status`

impliesOngoingInvestigationNeeded

True

V2 P2

Facts in this context

1942 Indigence File Rosie Hippie10 factsex:1942-indigence-file-rosie-hippie

1905 Chief Protector Report7 factsex:1905-chief-protector-report

Julia Leftwich Death Index 19866 factsex:julia-leftwich-death-index-1986

Source Table Section 46 factsex:source-table-section-4

1916 Removals Record5 factsex:1916-removals-record

1949 Marriage Exemption Register5 factsex:1949-marriage-exemption-register

Fred Leftwich Oral History5 factsex:fred-leftwich-oral-history

Port Douglas Hospital Death Record 19165 factsex:port-douglas-hospital-death-record-1916

Reaching Back Oral History5 factsex:reaching-back-oral-history

Yarrabah Marriage Record 19125 factsex:yarrabah-marriage-record-1912

Ged Death Year 1904 Source4 factsex:ged-death-year-1904-source

Julia4 factsex:julia

Source Table Section 54 factsex:source-table-section-5

Yarrabah Marriage Transcription 19124 factsex:yarrabah-marriage-transcription-1912

1901 Report3 factsex:1901-report

Daughters of 1916 Rosie3 factsex:daughters-of-1916-rosie

Julia Davis Link3 factsex:julia-davis-link

Next Steps Section 43 factsex:next-steps-section-4

Port Douglas Rosie 19163 factsex:port-douglas-rosie-1916

Port Douglas Rosie Death 19163 factsex:port-douglas-rosie-death-1916

Rosie Hippie3 factsex:rosie-hippie

Rosie Hippie Alive 19493 factsex:rosie-hippie-alive-1949

Rosie Hippie Homarlee Epi Julian3 factsex:rosie-hippie-homarlee-epi-julian

Three Incompatible Claims About Rosie3 factsex:three-incompatible-claims-about-rosie

1906 Brackenridge Birth Registrations2 factsex:1906-brackenridge-birth-registrations

1916 Removals Daughters of Rosie Deceased2 factsex:1916-removals-daughters-of-rosie-deceased

Ged Rosie Death 19042 factsex:ged-rosie-death-1904

Next Steps Section 52 factsex:next-steps-section-5

Rosie Mother Julia Nellie2 factsex:rosie-mother-julia-nellie

Section 4 Analysis2 factsex:section-4-analysis

Section 4 Rosie Rose Death Year2 factsex:section-4-rosie-rose-death-year

1912 Marriage Record1 factex:1912-marriage-record

1986 Death Index1 factex:1986-death-index

Daughters Aged 8 5 19161 factex:daughters-aged-8-5-1916

Davis1 factex:davis

Do Not Merge Rosies1 factex:do-not-merge-rosies

Evidence Points Toward1 factex:evidence-points-toward

Ged 1904 Date1 factex:ged-1904-date

Ged 1904 Death Date1 factex:ged-1904-death-date

Ged Source1 factex:ged-source

Julia Davis Rosie Connection1 factex:julia-davis-rosie-connection

Julia Death Cert Order1 factex:julia-death-cert-order

Julia in Tree1 factex:julia-in-tree

Julia Nunn1 factex:julia-nunn

Julia Nunn Later Account1 factex:julia-nunn-later-account

Marriage to Paddy Julian 19491 factex:marriage-to-paddy-julian-1949

Nellie Watkins1 factex:nellie-watkins

Order 1916 Port Douglas Death Record1 factex:order-1916-port-douglas-death-record

Parental Link Preservation1 factex:parental-link-preservation

Port Douglas Rosie 1916 Thread1 factex:port-douglas-rosie-1916-thread

Proof Requires1 factex:proof-requires

Rosie1 factex:rosie

Rosie Hippie Aliases1 factex:rosie-hippie-aliases

Rosie Hippie Homarlee Epi Thread1 factex:rosie-hippie-homarlee-epi-thread

Rosie Hippie Thread1 factex:rosie-hippie-thread

Search Death 1903 1905 Cooktown1 factex:search-death-1903-1905-cooktown

Section 4 Resolution1 factex:section-4-resolution

Section 5 Analysis1 factex:section-5-analysis

Section 5 Julia Nunn1 factex:section-5-julia-nunn

Section 5 Julia Nunn Connection1 factex:section-5-julia-nunn-connection

Section 5 Resolution1 factex:section-5-resolution

Text Author1 factex:text-author

Three Rosies Distinct1 factex:three-rosies-distinct

Tier 1 Sources1 factex:tier-1-sources

Tree Recommendation1 factex:tree-recommendation

Unresolved Status1 factex:unresolved-status

1942 Indigence File Rosie Hippie10 facts`ex:1942-indigence-file-rosie-hippie`

1905 Chief Protector Report7 facts`ex:1905-chief-protector-report`

Julia Leftwich Death Index 19866 facts`ex:julia-leftwich-death-index-1986`

Source Table Section 46 facts`ex:source-table-section-4`

1916 Removals Record5 facts`ex:1916-removals-record`

1949 Marriage Exemption Register5 facts`ex:1949-marriage-exemption-register`

Fred Leftwich Oral History5 facts`ex:fred-leftwich-oral-history`

Port Douglas Hospital Death Record 19165 facts`ex:port-douglas-hospital-death-record-1916`

Reaching Back Oral History5 facts`ex:reaching-back-oral-history`

Yarrabah Marriage Record 19125 facts`ex:yarrabah-marriage-record-1912`

Ged Death Year 1904 Source4 facts`ex:ged-death-year-1904-source`

Julia4 facts`ex:julia`

Source Table Section 54 facts`ex:source-table-section-5`

Yarrabah Marriage Transcription 19124 facts`ex:yarrabah-marriage-transcription-1912`

1901 Report3 facts`ex:1901-report`

Daughters of 1916 Rosie3 facts`ex:daughters-of-1916-rosie`

Julia Davis Link3 facts`ex:julia-davis-link`

Next Steps Section 43 facts`ex:next-steps-section-4`

Port Douglas Rosie 19163 facts`ex:port-douglas-rosie-1916`

Port Douglas Rosie Death 19163 facts`ex:port-douglas-rosie-death-1916`

Rosie Hippie3 facts`ex:rosie-hippie`

Rosie Hippie Alive 19493 facts`ex:rosie-hippie-alive-1949`

Rosie Hippie Homarlee Epi Julian3 facts`ex:rosie-hippie-homarlee-epi-julian`

Three Incompatible Claims About Rosie3 facts`ex:three-incompatible-claims-about-rosie`

1906 Brackenridge Birth Registrations2 facts`ex:1906-brackenridge-birth-registrations`

1916 Removals Daughters of Rosie Deceased2 facts`ex:1916-removals-daughters-of-rosie-deceased`

Ged Rosie Death 19042 facts`ex:ged-rosie-death-1904`

Next Steps Section 52 facts`ex:next-steps-section-5`

Rosie Mother Julia Nellie2 facts`ex:rosie-mother-julia-nellie`

Section 4 Analysis2 facts`ex:section-4-analysis`

Section 4 Rosie Rose Death Year2 facts`ex:section-4-rosie-rose-death-year`

1912 Marriage Record1 fact`ex:1912-marriage-record`

1986 Death Index1 fact`ex:1986-death-index`

Daughters Aged 8 5 19161 fact`ex:daughters-aged-8-5-1916`

Davis1 fact`ex:davis`

Do Not Merge Rosies1 fact`ex:do-not-merge-rosies`

Evidence Points Toward1 fact`ex:evidence-points-toward`

Ged 1904 Date1 fact`ex:ged-1904-date`

Ged 1904 Death Date1 fact`ex:ged-1904-death-date`

Ged Source1 fact`ex:ged-source`

Julia Davis Rosie Connection1 fact`ex:julia-davis-rosie-connection`

Julia Death Cert Order1 fact`ex:julia-death-cert-order`

Julia in Tree1 fact`ex:julia-in-tree`

Julia Nunn1 fact`ex:julia-nunn`

Julia Nunn Later Account1 fact`ex:julia-nunn-later-account`

Marriage to Paddy Julian 19491 fact`ex:marriage-to-paddy-julian-1949`

Nellie Watkins1 fact`ex:nellie-watkins`

Order 1916 Port Douglas Death Record1 fact`ex:order-1916-port-douglas-death-record`

Parental Link Preservation1 fact`ex:parental-link-preservation`

Port Douglas Rosie 1916 Thread1 fact`ex:port-douglas-rosie-1916-thread`

Proof Requires1 fact`ex:proof-requires`

Rosie1 fact`ex:rosie`

Rosie Hippie Aliases1 fact`ex:rosie-hippie-aliases`

Rosie Hippie Homarlee Epi Thread1 fact`ex:rosie-hippie-homarlee-epi-thread`

Rosie Hippie Thread1 fact`ex:rosie-hippie-thread`

Search Death 1903 1905 Cooktown1 fact`ex:search-death-1903-1905-cooktown`

Section 4 Resolution1 fact`ex:section-4-resolution`

Section 5 Analysis1 fact`ex:section-5-analysis`

Section 5 Julia Nunn1 fact`ex:section-5-julia-nunn`

Section 5 Julia Nunn Connection1 fact`ex:section-5-julia-nunn-connection`

Section 5 Resolution1 fact`ex:section-5-resolution`

Text Author1 fact`ex:text-author`

Three Rosies Distinct1 fact`ex:three-rosies-distinct`

Tier 1 Sources1 fact`ex:tier-1-sources`

Tree Recommendation1 fact`ex:tree-recommendation`

Unresolved Status1 fact`ex:unresolved-status`