Alfred Smart

as donto believed on

From Dontopedia, the open, paraconsistent wiki. (Last updated 2026-05-20.)

Alfred Smart has 72 facts recorded in Dontopedia across 4 references, with 6 live disagreements.

72 facts·57 predicates·4 sources·6 in dispute

Mostly:employs rhetorical strategy(6), offers justification(5), commits(3)

Inbound mentions (27)

Other subjects in dontopedia point AT this entity as a value. These are inverse relationships — e.g. "X motherOf this subject" — and answer questions the forward facts can't. Grouped by predicate.

`isCommittedBy`Is Committed by(3)

Acts of Intoxicationex:acts-of-intoxication
Failure to Make Returnsex:failure-to-make-returns
Neglect of Dutyex:neglect-of-duty

`hasAuthorityOver`Has Authority Over(2)

Commissioner of Policeex:commissioner-of-police
Reginald Uhrex:reginald-uhr

`admitsWrongdoing`Admits Wrongdoing(1)

Guilty Pleaex:guilty-plea

`areAdmittedBy`Are Admitted by(1)

Charges Against Smartex:charges-against-smart

`arePreferredAgainst`Are Preferred Against(1)

Charges Against Smartex:charges-against-smart

`areRequiredFrom`Are Required From(1)

Returnsex:returns

`broughtAgainst`Brought Against(1)

Charges Against Smart 1884ex:charges-against-smart-1884

`characterizeBehaviorNegatively`Characterize Behavior Negatively(1)

Charges Against Smartex:charges-against-smart

`hasAuthor`Has Author(1)

Letter Qsa847118ex:letter-qsa847118

`hasNamedPerpetrator1`Has Named Perpetrator1(1)

Nmp Event 25938ex:nmp-event-25938

`implicatesNmpGuiltViaResignationTiming`Implicates Nmp Guilt Via Resignation Timing(1)

Nmp Event 25938ex:nmp-event-25938

`isExpressedBy`Is Expressed by(1)

Wish to Plead Guiltyex:wish-to-plead-guilty

`isNeglectedBy`Is Neglected by(1)

Dutyex:duty

`isObligationOf`Is Obligation of(1)

Dutyex:duty

`isPleaFor`Is Plea for(1)

Plea of Guiltyex:plea-of-guilty

`isRankOf`Is Rank of(1)

Sub Inspectorex:sub-inspector

`performsSpeechActOfThreateningEnquiry`Performs Speech Act of Threatening Enquiry(1)

Dtsex:dts

`prefersChargesAgainst`Prefers Charges Against(1)

Reginald Uhrex:reginald-uhr

`providedInstructionTo`Provided Instruction to(1)

Sub Inspector Urqhartex:sub-inspector-urqhart

`recordsChargesAgainst`Records Charges Against(1)

Document Qsa847118ex:document-qsa847118

`recordsPleaOf`Records Plea of(1)

Document Qsa847118ex:document-qsa847118

`requireReturnsFrom`Require Returns From(1)

Proper Departmentsex:proper-departments

`suggestsResignationOrEnquiry`Suggests Resignation or Enquiry(1)

Dts Telegram 1883 10 24 to Smartex:dts-telegram-1883-10-24-to-smart

`withheldAssistanceFrom`Withheld Assistance From(1)

Sub Inspector Clerkex:sub-inspector-clerk

Other facts (72)

The long tail: predicates that appear too rarely to warrant their own section. Filter or scroll to find a specific one. Each row links to its source.

72 facts

Predicate	Value	Ref
Employs Rhetorical Strategy	Partial Admission	[4]
Employs Rhetorical Strategy	Blame Deflection	[4]
Employs Rhetorical Strategy	Appeal to Past Service	[4]
Employs Rhetorical Strategy	Promise of Reform	[4]
Employs Rhetorical Strategy	Self Portrayal As Clemency Giver	[4]
Employs Rhetorical Strategy	Minimization of Offense	[4]
Offers Justification	not being stricter with Sub Insp Clerk	[4]
Offers Justification	all the forms are altered since I had the honor to serve before	[4]
Offers Justification	there was no precedent to act upon	[4]
Offers Justification	Sub Insp Clerk would give me no assistance	[4]
Offers Justification	Sub Insp Clerk for the most part of his time very unwell	[4]
Commits	Acts of Intoxication	[3]
Commits	Neglect of Duty	[3]
Commits	Failure to Make Returns	[3]
Makes Admission	I have been much to blame this time	[4]
Makes Admission	I pleaded guilty	[4]
Makes Admission	I have taken more refreshment than I should have done	[4]
Holds Rank	Sub Inspector	[3]
Holds Rank	Sub Inspector 2c	[4]
Expresses Regret	Current Position	[4]
Expresses Regret	Clemency Toward Clerk	[4]
Goes As Overseer With Craig	Mr George Craig	[1]
Knocked Down Woman With Rifle Butt	Old Ugly Aboriginal Woman	[2]
Resigned Soon After Correspondence	October 1883 Correspondence	[2]
Essentially Knows Local People Since1868	since 68	[2]
Requested Transfer From Cloncurry In1884	Cloncurry	[2]
Has Name	Alfred Smart	[3]
Is Charged With	Charges Against Smart	[3]
Expresses Wish	Wish to Plead Guilty	[3]
Is Addressed As	Mr. Smart	[3]
Is Addressed With Honorific	Mr.	[3]
Is Subordinate to	Reginald Uhr	[3]
Admits to	Charges Against Smart	[3]
Pleads Guilty to	Charges Against Smart	[3]
Pleaded Guilty to	Charges Against Smart 1884	[4]
Attributes Trouble Origin to	Failure to Report Clerk	[4]
Refrained From Reporting	Sub Inspector Clerk	[4]
Held Impression	Clerk would stay only one or two weeks	[4]
Previously Served	Police Service	[4]
Recalls No Complaints	Prior Service Period	[4]
Lacked Precedent for	Bookkeeping Procedures	[4]
Performed All	Patrolling Duties	[4]
Acknowledges Deserving	Severe Reprimand	[4]
Received Lesson	Disciplinary Lesson 1884	[4]
Acknowledges Excess Consumption	Refreshment Alcohol	[4]
Claims Excess Was Rare	Refreshment Alcohol	[4]
Claims Current Capability	Bookkeeping Competence	[4]
Attributes Position to	Clemency Toward Clerk	[4]
Requests Leniency From	Commissioner of Police	[4]
Appeals to	Former Service Record	[4]
Confesses Blame	Current Situation	[4]
Promises Future Compliance	Commissioner of Police	[4]
Uses Formal Salutation	Sir	[4]
Uses Formal Closing	Your obedient servant	[4]
Implies Duty to Report	Sub Inspector Clerk	[4]
Implies Authority Over	Sub Inspector Clerk	[4]
Signs As	Alf Smart	[4]
Assumes Obligation to Keep	Books and Returns	[4]
Assumes Obligation to Perform	Patrolling Duties	[4]
Assumes Obligation to Report	Misconduct	[4]
Assumes Obligation of Temperance	Police Service	[4]
Claims Capability After	Urqhart Instruction	[4]
Expresses Sensibility	Deserving Reprimand	[4]
Expresses Trust	Commissioner of Police	[4]
Makes Positive Assertion	Future Compliance	[4]
Uses Hedge Word	some few remarks	[4]
Uses Honorific Language	had the honor to serve	[4]
Uses Self Deprecating Language	do the best I could	[4]
Has Educational Level	Basic Literacy	[4]
Addresses Superior	Reginald Uhr	[4]
Demonstrates Remorse	Disciplinary Action	[4]
Seeks Outcome	Lenient Treatment	[4]

Timeline axis is valid_time — when each source says the fact was true in the world, not when Dontopedia learned about it. Retracted rows are kept for provenance; coloured stripes indicate the context kind.

72 undated

—

goesAsOverseerWithCraigtrove-cooktown/beche-de-mer

ex:mr-george-craig

—

knockedDownWomanWithRifleButtrosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-1056-eid-25938

ex:old-ugly-aboriginal-woman

—

resignedSoonAfterCorrespondencerosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-1056-eid-25938

ex:october-1883-correspondence

—

essentiallyKnowsLocalPeopleSince1868rosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-1056-eid-25938

since 68

—

requestedTransferFromCloncurryIn1884rosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-1056-eid-25938

ex:cloncurry

—

hasNameblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056525--qsa847118-1884-statement-of-charges-against-alfred-smart-by-reginald-uhr,-in-letter-84:292

Alfred Smart

—

holdsRankblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056525--qsa847118-1884-statement-of-charges-against-alfred-smart-by-reginald-uhr,-in-letter-84:292

ex:sub-inspector

—

isChargedWithblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056525--qsa847118-1884-statement-of-charges-against-alfred-smart-by-reginald-uhr,-in-letter-84:292

ex:charges-against-smart

—

expressesWishblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056525--qsa847118-1884-statement-of-charges-against-alfred-smart-by-reginald-uhr,-in-letter-84:292

ex:wish-to-plead-guilty

—

isAddressedAsblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056525--qsa847118-1884-statement-of-charges-against-alfred-smart-by-reginald-uhr,-in-letter-84:292

Mr. Smart

—

isAddressedWithHonorificblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056525--qsa847118-1884-statement-of-charges-against-alfred-smart-by-reginald-uhr,-in-letter-84:292

Mr.

—

commitsblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056525--qsa847118-1884-statement-of-charges-against-alfred-smart-by-reginald-uhr,-in-letter-84:292

ex:acts-of-intoxication

—

commitsblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056525--qsa847118-1884-statement-of-charges-against-alfred-smart-by-reginald-uhr,-in-letter-84:292

ex:neglect-of-duty

—

commitsblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056525--qsa847118-1884-statement-of-charges-against-alfred-smart-by-reginald-uhr,-in-letter-84:292

ex:failure-to-make-returns

—

isSubordinateToblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056525--qsa847118-1884-statement-of-charges-against-alfred-smart-by-reginald-uhr,-in-letter-84:292

ex:reginald-uhr

—

admitsToblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056525--qsa847118-1884-statement-of-charges-against-alfred-smart-by-reginald-uhr,-in-letter-84:292

ex:charges-against-smart

—

pleadsGuiltyToblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056525--qsa847118-1884-statement-of-charges-against-alfred-smart-by-reginald-uhr,-in-letter-84:292

ex:charges-against-smart

—

holdsRankblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32040788--qsa847118-1884-letter-from-alfred-smart-to-reginald-uhr-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-coloni

ex:sub-inspector-2c

—

pleadedGuiltyToblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32040788--qsa847118-1884-letter-from-alfred-smart-to-reginald-uhr-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-coloni

ex:charges-against-smart-1884

—

attributesTroubleOriginToblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32040788--qsa847118-1884-letter-from-alfred-smart-to-reginald-uhr-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-coloni

ex:failure-to-report-clerk

—

refrainedFromReportingblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32040788--qsa847118-1884-letter-from-alfred-smart-to-reginald-uhr-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-coloni

ex:sub-inspector-clerk

—

heldImpressionblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32040788--qsa847118-1884-letter-from-alfred-smart-to-reginald-uhr-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-coloni

Clerk would stay only one or two weeks

—

previouslyServedblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32040788--qsa847118-1884-letter-from-alfred-smart-to-reginald-uhr-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-coloni

ex:police-service

—

recallsNoComplaintsblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32040788--qsa847118-1884-letter-from-alfred-smart-to-reginald-uhr-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-coloni

ex:prior-service-period

—

lackedPrecedentForblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32040788--qsa847118-1884-letter-from-alfred-smart-to-reginald-uhr-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-coloni

ex:bookkeeping-procedures

—

performedAllblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32040788--qsa847118-1884-letter-from-alfred-smart-to-reginald-uhr-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-coloni

ex:patrolling-duties

—

acknowledgesDeservingblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32040788--qsa847118-1884-letter-from-alfred-smart-to-reginald-uhr-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-coloni

ex:severe-reprimand

—

receivedLessonblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32040788--qsa847118-1884-letter-from-alfred-smart-to-reginald-uhr-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-coloni

ex:disciplinary-lesson-1884

—

acknowledgesExcessConsumptionblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32040788--qsa847118-1884-letter-from-alfred-smart-to-reginald-uhr-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-coloni

ex:refreshment-alcohol

—

claimsExcessWasRareblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32040788--qsa847118-1884-letter-from-alfred-smart-to-reginald-uhr-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-coloni

ex:refreshment-alcohol

—

claimsCurrentCapabilityblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32040788--qsa847118-1884-letter-from-alfred-smart-to-reginald-uhr-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-coloni

ex:bookkeeping-competence

—

expressesRegretblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32040788--qsa847118-1884-letter-from-alfred-smart-to-reginald-uhr-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-coloni

ex:current-position

—

attributesPositionToblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32040788--qsa847118-1884-letter-from-alfred-smart-to-reginald-uhr-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-coloni

ex:clemency-toward-clerk

—

requestsLeniencyFromblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32040788--qsa847118-1884-letter-from-alfred-smart-to-reginald-uhr-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-coloni

ex:commissioner-of-police

—

appealsToblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32040788--qsa847118-1884-letter-from-alfred-smart-to-reginald-uhr-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-coloni

ex:former-service-record

—

confessesBlameblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32040788--qsa847118-1884-letter-from-alfred-smart-to-reginald-uhr-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-coloni

ex:current-situation

—

promisesFutureComplianceblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32040788--qsa847118-1884-letter-from-alfred-smart-to-reginald-uhr-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-coloni

ex:commissioner-of-police

—

usesFormalSalutationblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32040788--qsa847118-1884-letter-from-alfred-smart-to-reginald-uhr-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-coloni

Sir

—

usesFormalClosingblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32040788--qsa847118-1884-letter-from-alfred-smart-to-reginald-uhr-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-coloni

Your obedient servant

—