Sub Inspector Clerk

as donto believed on

From Dontopedia, the open, paraconsistent wiki. (Last updated 2026-05-20.)

Sub Inspector Clerk has 84 facts recorded in Dontopedia across 3 references, with 4 live disagreements.

84 facts·76 predicates·3 sources·4 in dispute

Mostly:challenged urquhart on(5), has surname(2), denied being(2)

Inbound mentions (22)

Other subjects in dontopedia point AT this entity as a value. These are inverse relationships — e.g. "X motherOf this subject" — and answer questions the forward facts can't. Grouped by predicate.

`accompanied`Accompanied(1)

Mr Martinex:mr-martin

`appliesTo`Applies to(1)

Dismissal Decisionex:dismissal-decision

`belongsTo`Belongs to(1)

Conduct of Clerkex:conduct-of-clerk

`claimedUrquhartAbused`Claimed Urquhart Abused(1)

Sub Inspector Clerkex:sub-inspector-clerk

`claimedUrquhartDisliked`Claimed Urquhart Disliked(1)

Sub Inspector Clerkex:sub-inspector-clerk

`claimsToHaveSeen`Claims to Have Seen(1)

Frederick Charles Urquhartex:frederick-charles-urquhart

`concernsConductOf`Concerns Conduct of(1)

Enquiry Instructionsex:enquiry-instructions

`deniesAbusing`Denies Abusing(1)

Frederick Charles Urquhartex:frederick-charles-urquhart

`deniesDisliking`Denies Disliking(1)

Frederick Charles Urquhartex:frederick-charles-urquhart

`hasAuthorityOver`Has Authority Over(1)

Commissioner of Policeex:commissioner-of-police

`hasSuperiorRankOver`Has Superior Rank Over(1)

Frederick Charles Urquhartex:frederick-charles-urquhart

`impliesAuthorityOver`Implies Authority Over(1)

Alfred Smartex:alfred-smart

`impliesDutyToReport`Implies Duty to Report(1)

Alfred Smartex:alfred-smart

`impliesPossessionBy`Implies Possession by(1)

Clerk Horseex:clerk-horse

`initiatedInteractionWith`Initiated Interaction With(1)

Frederick Charles Urquhartex:frederick-charles-urquhart

`insulted`Insulted(1)

Frederick Charles Urquhartex:frederick-charles-urquhart

`investigates`Investigates(1)

Enquiry Clerk Smartex:enquiry-clerk-smart

`isPotentialWitnessFor`Is Potential Witness for(1)

Mr Martinex:mr-martin

`knows`Knows(1)

Frederick Charles Urquhartex:frederick-charles-urquhart

`prefersChargeAgainst`Prefers Charge Against(1)

Frederick Charles Urquhartex:frederick-charles-urquhart

`refrainedFromReporting`Refrained From Reporting(1)

Alfred Smartex:alfred-smart

`wasInformedBy`Was Informed by(1)

Fitzroyex:fitzroy

Other facts (84)

The long tail: predicates that appear too rarely to warrant their own section. Filter or scroll to find a specific one. Each row links to its source.

84 facts

Predicate	Value	Ref
Challenged Urquhart on	Initial Sighting Location	[3]
Challenged Urquhart on	Horse Pull Up Cause	[3]
Challenged Urquhart on	Companions Present	[3]
Challenged Urquhart on	Departure Companions	[3]
Challenged Urquhart on	Martin Initial Presence	[3]
Has Surname	Clerk	[1]
Has Surname	Clerk	[3]
Denied Being	Black Boy	[3]
Denied Being	Hottentot	[3]
Claimed Urquhart Had	Strong Dislike to Clerk	[3]
Claimed Urquhart Had	Spoken Abusively of Clerk	[3]
Implies Disdain for	Indigenous Status	[3]
Implies Disdain for	Hottentot Status	[3]
Has Rank	Sub-Inspector	[1]
Subject to Enquiry	Enquiry Clerk Smart	[1]
Subject to Dismissal	Dismissal Decision	[1]
Was Present at	Enquiry Clerk Smart	[1]
Is Police Officer	Police Officer	[1]
Has Gender	male	[1]
Committed Misconduct	Alleged Misconduct	[1]
Committed Aggression	First Aggression Clerk	[2]
Expected to Proceed to	Lake Nash	[2]
Withheld Assistance From	Alfred Smart	[2]
Failed to Explain	Books and Returns	[2]
Was Unwell	Most of His Time	[2]
Has Title	Sub Insp	[2]
Has Position	Sub Inspector	[3]
Is Accused in	Deposition Qsa847118	[3]
Cross Examines	Frederick Charles Urquhart	[3]
Was Located at	Verandah Jaimesons Hotel	[3]
Had Back Turned to	Frederick Charles Urquhart	[3]
Was Speaking in	Loud Voice	[3]
Was Amongst	Mixed Crowd	[3]
Agreed to	Come Out	[3]
Began to	Exit Verandah	[3]
Returned Almost Immediately	Verandah Jaimesons Hotel	[3]
Called Out to	Frederick Charles Urquhart	[3]
Asked Why	Frederick Charles Urquhart	[3]
Uttered	Statement Bloody Horse	[3]
Expressed Gratitude to	God	[3]
Claimed Inability to	Get Another Horse	[3]
Promised to	Deliver Horse to Urquhart	[3]
Refused	Hang Up Horse	[3]
Denied Urquhart Right to	Have Opinion About Clerk	[3]
Questioned Identity of	Frederick Charles Urquhart	[3]
Was in State	Excited	[3]
Appeared to Be	Intoxicated	[3]
Told	Fitzroy	[3]
Reported to	Fitzroy	[3]
Expressed Disdain for	Urquhart Horse	[3]
Resisted Authority of	Frederick Charles Urquhart	[3]
Insulted	Frederick Charles Urquhart	[3]
Claimed Urquhart Disliked	Sub Inspector Clerk	[3]
Claimed Urquhart Abused	Sub Inspector Clerk	[3]
Challenges	Urquhart Testimony	[3]
Performs	Speech Act Cross Examination	[3]
Invokes Racial Hierarchy With	Not Black Boy Statement	[3]
Addressed As	Mr Clerk	[3]
Addressed Urquhart As	Urquhart	[3]
Used Profanity	Bloody	[3]
Used Profanity Multiple Times	2	[3]
Was on Horseback	true	[3]
Refers to Horse As	him	[3]
Was at	Hotel Verandah	[3]
Was Speaking to	Mixed Crowd	[3]
Was in Public Place	true	[3]
Was Not Alone	true	[3]
Initially Complied With	Urquhart Request	[3]
Then Reversed	Compliance With Request	[3]
Attempted to Summon	Frederick Charles Urquhart	[3]
Questioned Authority of	Frederick Charles Urquhart	[3]
Rejected Control by	Frederick Charles Urquhart	[3]
Rejected Horse From	Frederick Charles Urquhart	[3]
Claimed Ability to	Get Own Horse	[3]
Expressed Sarcasm About	Horse Transport	[3]
Resisted	Urquhart Authority	[3]
Spread Information About	Frederick Charles Urquhart	[3]
Portrayed Negatively	Frederick Charles Urquhart	[3]
Claimed to Have Greeted	Frederick Charles Urquhart	[3]
Implied Urquhart Reacted to	Clerk Greeting	[3]
Attempted to Establish	Urquhart Acknowledged Him	[3]
Presented by Urquhart As	Unprofessional	[3]
Presents Self As	Wronged Party	[3]
Claims Urquhart Has	Animus Against Clerk	[3]

Timeline axis is valid_time — when each source says the fact was true in the world, not when Dontopedia learned about it. Retracted rows are kept for provenance; coloured stripes indicate the context kind.

84 undated

—

hasSurnameblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32040797--qsa847118-1884-letter-from-reginald-uhr-to-colonial-secretary-28-march,-in-letter-84:2927-

Clerk

—

hasRankblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32040797--qsa847118-1884-letter-from-reginald-uhr-to-colonial-secretary-28-march,-in-letter-84:2927-

Sub-Inspector

—

subjectToEnquiryblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32040797--qsa847118-1884-letter-from-reginald-uhr-to-colonial-secretary-28-march,-in-letter-84:2927-

ex:enquiry-clerk-smart

—

subjectToDismissalblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32040797--qsa847118-1884-letter-from-reginald-uhr-to-colonial-secretary-28-march,-in-letter-84:2927-

ex:dismissal-decision

—

wasPresentAtblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32040797--qsa847118-1884-letter-from-reginald-uhr-to-colonial-secretary-28-march,-in-letter-84:2927-

ex:enquiry-clerk-smart

—

isPoliceOfficerblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32040797--qsa847118-1884-letter-from-reginald-uhr-to-colonial-secretary-28-march,-in-letter-84:2927-

ex:police-officer

—

hasGenderblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32040797--qsa847118-1884-letter-from-reginald-uhr-to-colonial-secretary-28-march,-in-letter-84:2927-

male

—

committedMisconductblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32040797--qsa847118-1884-letter-from-reginald-uhr-to-colonial-secretary-28-march,-in-letter-84:2927-

ex:alleged-misconduct

—

committedAggressionblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32040788--qsa847118-1884-letter-from-alfred-smart-to-reginald-uhr-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-coloni

ex:first-aggression-clerk

—

expectedToProceedToblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32040788--qsa847118-1884-letter-from-alfred-smart-to-reginald-uhr-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-coloni

ex:lake-nash

—

withheldAssistanceFromblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32040788--qsa847118-1884-letter-from-alfred-smart-to-reginald-uhr-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-coloni

ex:alfred-smart

—

failedToExplainblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32040788--qsa847118-1884-letter-from-alfred-smart-to-reginald-uhr-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-coloni

ex:books-and-returns

—

wasUnwellblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32040788--qsa847118-1884-letter-from-alfred-smart-to-reginald-uhr-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-coloni

ex:most-of-his-time

—

hasTitleblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32040788--qsa847118-1884-letter-from-alfred-smart-to-reginald-uhr-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-coloni

Sub Insp

—

hasPositionblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

ex:sub-inspector

—

isAccusedInblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

ex:deposition-qsa847118

—

crossExaminesblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

ex:frederick-charles-urquhart

—

wasLocatedAtblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

ex:verandah-jaimesons-hotel

—

hadBackTurnedToblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

ex:frederick-charles-urquhart

—

wasSpeakingInblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

ex:loud-voice

—

wasAmongstblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

ex:mixed-crowd

—

agreedToblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

ex:come-out

—

beganToblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

ex:exit-verandah

—

returnedAlmostImmediatelyblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

ex:verandah-jaimesons-hotel

—

calledOutToblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

ex:frederick-charles-urquhart

—

askedWhyblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

ex:frederick-charles-urquhart

—

utteredblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

ex:statement-bloody-horse

—

expressedGratitudeToblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

ex:god

—

claimedInabilityToblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

ex:get-another-horse

—

promisedToblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

ex:deliver-horse-to-urquhart

—

refusedblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

ex:hang-up-horse

—

deniedBeingblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

ex:black-boy

—

deniedUrquhartRightToblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

ex:have-opinion-about-clerk

—

deniedBeingblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

ex:hottentot

—

questionedIdentityOfblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

ex:frederick-charles-urquhart

—

wasInStateblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

ex:excited

—

appearedToBeblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

ex:intoxicated

—

toldblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

ex:fitzroy

—

reportedToblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

ex:fitzroy

—

claimedUrquhartHadblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

ex:strong-dislike-to-clerk

—

claimedUrquhartHadblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

ex:spoken-abusively-of-clerk

—

expressedDisdainForblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

ex:urquhart-horse

—

resistedAuthorityOfblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

ex:frederick-charles-urquhart

—

insultedblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

ex:frederick-charles-urquhart

—

claimedUrquhartDislikedblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

ex:sub-inspector-clerk

—

claimedUrquhartAbusedblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

ex:sub-inspector-clerk

—

challengesblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

ex:urquhart-testimony

—

performsblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

ex:speech-act-cross-examination

—

impliesDisdainForblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

ex:indigenous-status

—

impliesDisdainForblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

ex:hottentot-status

—

invokesRacialHierarchyWithblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

ex:not-black-boy-statement

—

hasSurnameblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

Clerk

—

addressedAsblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

Mr Clerk

—

addressedUrquhartAsblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

Urquhart

—

usedProfanityblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

Bloody

—

usedProfanityMultipleTimesblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

—

wasOnHorsebackblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

true

—

refersToHorseAsblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

him

—

wasAtblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

ex:hotel-verandah

—

wasSpeakingToblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

ex:mixed-crowd

—

wasInPublicPlaceblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

true

—

wasNotAloneblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

true

—

initiallyCompliedWithblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

ex:urquhart-request

—

thenReversedblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

ex:compliance-with-request

—

attemptedToSummonblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

ex:frederick-charles-urquhart

—

questionedAuthorityOfblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

ex:frederick-charles-urquhart

—

rejectedControlByblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

ex:frederick-charles-urquhart

—

rejectedHorseFromblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

ex:frederick-charles-urquhart

—

claimedAbilityToblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

ex:get-own-horse

—

expressedSarcasmAboutblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

ex:horse-transport

—

resistedblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

ex:urquhart-authority

—

spreadInformationAboutblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

ex:frederick-charles-urquhart

—

portrayedNegativelyblucher-uhr/sqlite--qsa-32056523--qsa847118-1884-deposition-of-frederick-urquhart-27-march,-in-letter-84:2927-colonial-secre

ex:frederick-charles-urquhart

—