Dontopedia
Explore

Mr Justice Harding

From Dontopedia, the open, paraconsistent wiki. (Last updated 2026-07-03.)

Mr Justice Harding has 100 facts recorded in Dontopedia across 26 references, with 4 live disagreements.

100+ facts·93 predicates·26 sources·4 in dispute

Mostly:interviewed by(3), annoyed by(2), delivers judgment in(2)

Maturity scale raw canonical shape-checked rule-derived certified

Annoyed byin disputeannoyedBy

Delivers Judgment inin disputedeliversJudgmentIn

Heard Application in Chambersin disputeheardApplicationInChambers

  • Thursday[11]all time · Cingalese
  • null[10]all time · John Davis

Expresses Desire toin disputeexpressesDesireTo

Interviewed byinterviewedBy

Never Took Active Part inneverTookActivePartIn

Granted OrdergrantedOrder

Criticized InterpretercriticizedInterpreter

Commented UponcommentedUpon

  • plaintiff had not actually proved his connection with the libel[14]all time · Trove Maytown Service Brought Rosey Children 3539375

Deprecateddeprecated

  • actions being brought without proper preparation[14]all time · Trove Maytown Service Brought Rosey Children 3539375

Made Sharp Comments onmadeSharpCommentsOn

  • manner in which the plaintiff's case had been got up[14]all time · Trove Maytown Service Brought Rosey Children 3539375

Annoyed by Witness Name CallingannoyedByWitnessNameCalling

  • true[7]all time · Trove 4492051 James Reynolds Mowbray Black Boy Targeted Windows

Inbound mentions (56)

Other subjects in dontopedia point AT this entity as a value. These are inverse relationships — e.g. "X motherOf this subject" — and answer questions the forward facts can't. Grouped by predicate.

presidedByPresided by(7)

beforeBefore(4)

judgeJudge(3)

presidedOverByPresided Over by(3)

beforeJudgeBefore Judge(2)

triedBeforeTried Before(2)

acquittedByDirectionOfAcquitted by Direction of(1)

adjudicatedBeforeAdjudicated Before(1)

adjudicatedInsolventBeforeAdjudicated Insolvent Before(1)

advocatesReversalOfDamagesAdvocates Reversal of Damages(1)

againstJudgmentByAgainst Judgment by(1)

agreedWithAgreed With(1)

assignedToAssigned to(1)

assignedToJudgeAssigned to Judge(1)

assistedByAssisted by(1)

beforeJudgesBefore Judges(1)

broughtToNoticeOfBrought to Notice of(1)

causedSuggestionToAmendPleadingsCaused Suggestion to Amend Pleadings(1)

civilSittingsBeforeCivil Sittings Before(1)

commenceBeforeCommence Before(1)

commencesBeforeCommences Before(1)

commencesMondayNextBeforeCommences Monday Next Before(1)

concurredWithConcurred With(1)

experiencedByExperienced by(1)

heardByHeard by(1)

heldBeforeHeld Before(1)

informedInformed(1)

inInsolvencyIn Insolvency(1)

judgmentByJudgment by(1)

likelyRefersToLikely Refers to(1)

madeByMade by(1)

presentedToJudgePresented to Judge(1)

presidedFullCourtWithPresided Full Court With(1)

purposeAttendingByOfficialsPurpose Attending by Officials(1)

sentencedToDeathBySentenced to Death by(1)

sessionInChambersSession in Chambers(1)

submittedDamagesWronglyAssessedSubmitted Damages Wrongly Assessed(1)

submittedJudgeMightDirectInquiryForCorrectAmountSubmitted Judge Might Direct Inquiry for Correct Amount(1)

tookSeatUsuallyOccupiedByTook Seat Usually Occupied by(1)

wasRampantWhenFirstOnCircuitWas Rampant When First on Circuit(1)

wifeOfWife of(1)

Other facts (81)

The long tail: predicates that appear too rarely to warrant their own section. Filter or scroll to find a specific one. Each row links to its source.

81 facts
PredicateValueRef
Delivered Judgment inBooroodabin Board V Brisbane Corporation[7]
Decides forBooroodabin Board Claim[6]
Bases Views onExperience in London[12]
Disclaims Own OpinionNo Politician[12]
Frames As Observation Not OpinionPolitical Views[12]
Neutral on PoliticsSeparation Federation[12]
ConcludesCivil Sittings of Supreme Court[5]
Delivers JudgmentBooroodabin Board V Brisbane Corporation[5]
Appointed Member and Chairman Supreme Court Library Committee1893null[9]
Acted As Presiding JudgeAbsence Chief Justice[2]
Administered Oath toMr Justice Windeyer[2]
Decided Not to Sit on Appeals{}[2]
Majority DecisionGrant Application[26]
ExperiencedColonial Office London[19]
Gives No Own OpinionThese Views[19]
Is NoPolitician[19]
Never Took Part inPolitics[19]
Anticipates Gaining Knowledge FromStatement[8]
Clarified ThatIt is not an application. It is bringing my geography up to date[8]
Contrasted WithSecretary of State[8]
Denied Giving SuggestionsMr Feez[8]
Frames Issue Aslesson in geography[8]
Has Rolejudge[8]
Interpreted Act Asthis court had to apply to the Secretary of State direct[8]
Made Humorous Remark AboutMighell V Sultan of Johore[8]
Never Gave Suggestion toMr Feez[8]
Gives No Personal Opinion{}[20]
Is No Politician{}[20]
Context Recent Europe Visitnull[16]
Disclaims Personal Viewnull[16]
Experienced WithColonial Office[16]
Gathered Prevailing Opinion ThatNon Interference Until Local Sanction[16]
Giving No Personal Opinionnull[16]
No Politiciannull[16]
Left Cards atLady Normans Reception[25]
Decides Right Restricted to Natural Conditiontrue[4]
Advises Jury Dig Rootsnull[4]
Denied Costsnull[4]
Infers Malice From No Causenull[4]
Notes Apparent Contradictionsnull[4]
Is Acting Chief Justice{}[11]
Made Order As Prayed{}[11]
Authorized by Auctioneers Actto sell estate goods effects but not illegal acts[10]
Interpreted Distillers Act Asunlawful to sell spirits without registration[10]
Granted Rule Nisitrue[22]
Has AssociateMr John O Hara Wood[23]
Leaves forMaryborough Circuit Court[4]
Decided Pleadings Amended According to Evidence JudgmentTavares V Holland[4]
Believes Not WarrantedCosts[13]
Declined to Add CostsJames Brimer Verdict[13]
Did Not Consider Case Warranted Coststrue[13]
Made Order Absolutesetting aside garnishee with costs[13]
Kind Friend toThe Bar[1]
Granted Order for Dischargenull[10]
Could Not Hear Applicationtrue[11]
Away on CircuitRockhampton[11]
Is Passenger onTaroba[11]
Acknowledges Greatest Provocation PossibleAdultery[1]
Mitigates Sentence Due to ProvocationWilliam Wigg[1]
Disposed of BusinessCircuit Business[10]
Heard Petition onSaturday last[1]
Holds RoleActing Chief Justice[24]
Congratulates Colony onCrime Diminution[15]
Congratulates Sheriff and ColonyState of Crime[15]
First Time Since on Bench Such EventPleasurable Event[15]
Gives Reasons for Diminishing Punishmentreasons[15]
Had One Case Preceding CircuitCertain Crime[15]
Hopes Commencement of Similar SittingsSimilar Empty Sittings[15]
Evaluates Amendment As Advisablenull[10]
Interpreted Auctioneers Act Asauthorises selling goods but not illegal acts[10]
Departs by SteamerLady Bowen[18]
DestinationRockhampton[18]
Desires Not Known As'Bloody assize'[1]
Administers Reprimand toDr Robertson[1]
Expressed Desire to Mr Pringnot known as Bloody Assize[1]
Expresses Impatience WithMr Feez[8]
Lacks Current Knowledge ofGeography of Malaita[8]
Implies Right Restricted by Population at Board Formationtrue[4]
Has Inexperience inCriminal Business[4]
ActionTook Vacation Chamber Business[3]
NameMr. Justice Harding[3]

Timeline

Timeline axis is valid_time — when each source says the fact was true in the world, not when Dontopedia learned about it. Retracted rows are kept for provenance; coloured stripes indicate the context kind.

acknowledgesGreatestProvocationPossibletrove-cooktown/beche-de-mer
ex:adultery
actedAsPresidingJudgebrackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/trove-new/123021752_Saturday-17-September-1892_Our-Brisbane-Letter-Friday-September-16
ex:absence-chief-justice
actiondocument/01462124-0fb4-4a88-9152-4ddb84e6bdc1
ex:took-vacation-chamber-business
administeredOathTobrackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/trove-new/123021752_Saturday-17-September-1892_Our-Brisbane-Letter-Friday-September-16
ex:mr-justice-windeyer
administersReprimandTotrove-cooktown/beche-de-mer
ex:dr-robertson
advisesJuryDigRootstrove-cooktown/reynolds
null
annoyedByrosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/trove-article-4492051
ex:miscalled-witness-names
annoyedByrosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/trove-james-reynolds-cattle-creek-mowbray-hotel-4492051
ex:witness-name-calling
annoyedByWitnessNameCallingrosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/trove-4492051-james-reynolds-mowbray-black-boy-targeted-windows
true
anticipatesGainingKnowledgeFrombrackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/trove-new/183705377_Friday-15-March-1895-charge-of-kidnapping-william-manson-cases-supreme-court-crim
ex:statement
appointedMemberAndChairmanSupremeCourtLibraryCommittee1893rosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/metadata-reingest/04-trove-nla-gov-au-newspaper-article-19829918-f6af5d5cd8e0
null
authorizedByAuctioneersActtrove-cooktown/john-davis
to sell estate goods effects but not illegal acts
awayOnCircuittrove-cooktown/cingalese
ex:rockhampton
basesViewsOnrosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/trove-article-291085937
ex:experience-in-london
believesNotWarrantedtrove-cooktown/prostitution
ex:costs
clarifiedThatbrackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/trove-new/183705377_Friday-15-March-1895-charge-of-kidnapping-william-manson-cases-supreme-court-crim
It is not an application. It is bringing my geography up to date
commentedUponrosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/trove-maytown-service-brought-rosey-children-3539375
plaintiff had not actually proved his connection with the libel
concludesrosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/trove-article-4492051
ex:civil-sittings-of-supreme-court
congratulatesColonyOntrove-cooktown/coloured-persons
ex:crime-diminution
congratulatesSheriffAndColonytrove-cooktown/coloured-persons
ex:state-of-crime
contextRecentEuropeVisitlaura-corridor/loop10-reynolds-corridor
null
contrastedWithbrackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/trove-new/183705377_Friday-15-March-1895-charge-of-kidnapping-william-manson-cases-supreme-court-crim
ex:secretary-of-state
couldNotHearApplicationtrove-cooktown/cingalese
true
criticizedInterpreterrosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-0978-eid-23581
ex:archie
decidedNotToSitOnAppealsbrackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/trove-new/123021752_Saturday-17-September-1892_Our-Brisbane-Letter-Friday-September-16
{}
decidedPleadingsAmendedAccordingToEvidenceJudgmenttrove-cooktown/reynolds
ex:tavares-v-holland
decidesForrosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/trove-james-reynolds-cattle-creek-mowbray-hotel-4492051
ex:booroodabin-board-claim
decidesRightRestrictedToNaturalConditiontrove-cooktown/reynolds
true
declinedToAddCoststrove-cooktown/prostitution
ex:james-brimer-verdict
deliveredJudgmentInrosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/trove-4492051-james-reynolds-mowbray-black-boy-targeted-windows
ex:booroodabin-board-v-brisbane-corporation
deliversJudgmentrosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/trove-article-4492051
ex:booroodabin-board-v-brisbane-corporation
deliversJudgmentIntrove-cooktown/reynolds
ex:booroodabin-divisional-board-v-corporation-of-brisbane
deliversJudgmentInrosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/trove-james-reynolds-cattle-creek-mowbray-hotel-4492051
ex:booroodabin-v-brisbane
deniedCoststrove-cooktown/reynolds
null
deniedGivingSuggestionsbrackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/trove-new/183705377_Friday-15-March-1895-charge-of-kidnapping-william-manson-cases-supreme-court-crim
ex:mr-feez
departsBySteamertrove-cooktown/north-shore-cooktown
ex:lady-bowen
deprecatedrosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/trove-maytown-service-brought-rosey-children-3539375
actions being brought without proper preparation
desiresNotKnownAstrove-cooktown/beche-de-mer
'Bloody assize'
destinationtrove-cooktown/north-shore-cooktown
ex:rockhampton
didNotConsiderCaseWarrantedCoststrove-cooktown/prostitution
true
disclaimsOwnOpinionrosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/trove-article-291085937
ex:no-politician
disclaimsPersonalViewlaura-corridor/loop10-reynolds-corridor
null
disposedOfBusinesstrove-cooktown/john-davis
ex:circuit-business
evaluatesAmendmentAsAdvisabletrove-cooktown/john-davis
null
experiencedbrackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/trove-new/291085937_Friday-12-December-1890-telegraphic-news-cairns-dec-9
ex:colonial-office-london
experiencedWithlaura-corridor/loop10-reynolds-corridor
ex:colonial-office
expressedDesireToMrPringtrove-cooktown/beche-de-mer
not known as Bloody Assize
expressesDesireTotrove-cooktown/beche-de-mer
ex:mr-pring
expressesDesireTotrove-cooktown/beche-de-mer
ex:mr-pringle
expressesImpatienceWithbrackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/trove-new/183705377_Friday-15-March-1895-charge-of-kidnapping-william-manson-cases-supreme-court-crim
ex:mr-feez
firstTimeSinceOnBenchSuchEventtrove-cooktown/coloured-persons
ex:pleasurable-event
framesAsObservationNotOpinionrosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/trove-article-291085937
ex:political-views
framesIssueAsbrackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/trove-new/183705377_Friday-15-March-1895-charge-of-kidnapping-william-manson-cases-supreme-court-crim
lesson in geography
gatheredPrevailingOpinionThatlaura-corridor/loop10-reynolds-corridor
ex:non-interference-until-local-sanction
givesNoOwnOpinionbrackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/trove-new/291085937_Friday-12-December-1890-telegraphic-news-cairns-dec-9
ex:these-views
givesNoPersonalOpinionlaura-corridor/loop11-hodgkinson
{}
givesReasonsForDiminishingPunishmenttrove-cooktown/coloured-persons
reasons
givingNoPersonalOpinionlaura-corridor/loop10-reynolds-corridor
null
grantedOrderrosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-1987-eid-56231
ex:produce-johnny-campbell
grantedOrderForDischargetrove-cooktown/john-davis
null
grantedRuleNisitrove-cooktown/north-shore-full
true
hadOneCasePrecedingCircuittrove-cooktown/coloured-persons
ex:certain-crime
hasAssociatetrove-cooktown/watkins
ex:mr-john-o-hara-wood
hasInexperienceIntrove-cooktown/reynolds
ex:criminal-business
hasRolebrackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/trove-new/183705377_Friday-15-March-1895-charge-of-kidnapping-william-manson-cases-supreme-court-crim
judge
heardApplicationInChamberstrove-cooktown/cingalese
Thursday
heardApplicationInChamberstrove-cooktown/john-davis
null
heardPetitionOntrove-cooktown/beche-de-mer
Saturday last
holdsRoletrove-cooktown/mauritius-queensland
Acting Chief Justice
hopesCommencementOfSimilarSittingstrove-cooktown/coloured-persons
ex:similar-empty-sittings
impliesRightRestrictedByPopulationAtBoardFormationtrove-cooktown/reynolds
true
infersMaliceFromNoCausetrove-cooktown/reynolds
null
interpretedActAsbrackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/trove-new/183705377_Friday-15-March-1895-charge-of-kidnapping-william-manson-cases-supreme-court-crim
this court had to apply to the Secretary of State direct
interpretedAuctioneersActAstrove-cooktown/john-davis
authorises selling goods but not illegal acts
interpretedDistillersActAstrove-cooktown/john-davis
unlawful to sell spirits without registration
interviewedBybrackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/trove-new/291085937_Friday-12-December-1890-telegraphic-news-cairns-dec-9
ex:courier-reporter
interviewedBylaura-corridor/loop10-reynolds-corridor
ex:courier-reporter
interviewedByrosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/trove-article-291085937
ex:courier-reporter
isActingChiefJusticetrove-cooktown/cingalese
{}
isNobrackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/trove-new/291085937_Friday-12-December-1890-telegraphic-news-cairns-dec-9
ex:politician
isNoPoliticianlaura-corridor/loop11-hodgkinson
{}
isPassengerOntrove-cooktown/cingalese
ex:taroba
kindFriendTotrove-cooktown/beche-de-mer
ex:the-bar
lacksCurrentKnowledgeOfbrackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/trove-new/183705377_Friday-15-March-1895-charge-of-kidnapping-william-manson-cases-supreme-court-crim
ex:geography-of-malaita
leavesFortrove-cooktown/reynolds
ex:maryborough-circuit-court
leftCardsAtlaura-corridor/loop9-stations
ex:lady-normans-reception
madeHumorousRemarkAboutbrackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/trove-new/183705377_Friday-15-March-1895-charge-of-kidnapping-william-manson-cases-supreme-court-crim
ex:mighell-v-sultan-of-johore
madeOrderAbsolutetrove-cooktown/prostitution
setting aside garnishee with costs
madeOrderAsPrayedtrove-cooktown/cingalese
{}
madeSharpCommentsOnrosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/trove-maytown-service-brought-rosey-children-3539375
manner in which the plaintiff's case had been got up
majorityDecisionbrackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/trove-new/3579503_Thursday-10-May-1894-the-ministerial-party
ex:grant-application
mitigatesSentenceDueToProvocationtrove-cooktown/beche-de-mer
ex:william-wigg
namedocument/01462124-0fb4-4a88-9152-4ddb84e6bdc1
Mr. Justice Harding
neutralOnPoliticsrosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/trove-article-291085937
ex:separation-federation
neverGaveSuggestionTobrackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/trove-new/183705377_Friday-15-March-1895-charge-of-kidnapping-william-manson-cases-supreme-court-crim
ex:mr-feez
neverTookActivePartInlaura-corridor/loop10-reynolds-corridor
ex:politics
neverTookActivePartInlaura-corridor/loop11-hodgkinson
ex:politics
neverTookPartInbrackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/trove-new/291085937_Friday-12-December-1890-telegraphic-news-cairns-dec-9
ex:politics
noPoliticianlaura-corridor/loop10-reynolds-corridor
null
notesApparentContradictionstrove-cooktown/reynolds
null

References (26)

26 references
  1. [1]Beche De Mer9 facts
    customctx:genes/trove-cooktown/beche-de-mer
  2. customctx:genes/brackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/trove-new/123021752_Saturday-17-September-1892_Our-Brisbane-Letter-Friday-September-16
  3. trove.nla.gov.aucustomctx:claims/document/01462124-0fb4-4a88-9152-4ddb84e6bdc1
    • text/plain38 KBtrove:article/3490149
      Show excerpt
      20 Dec 1888 - The Brisbane Courier Brisbane Courier (Qld. : 1864 - 1933), Thursday 20 December 1888, page 4 Wm IJtfetow* ëuxm THURSDAY, DECEMBER 20, ms. THE political «isis in New South \Vale3 has come to an end. "Few people really believed
  4. [4]Reynolds10 facts
    customctx:genes/trove-cooktown/reynolds
  5. customctx:genes/rosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/trove-article-4492051
  6. customctx:genes/rosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/trove-james-reynolds-cattle-creek-mowbray-hotel-4492051
  7. customctx:genes/rosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/trove-4492051-james-reynolds-mowbray-black-boy-targeted-windows
  8. customctx:genes/brackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/trove-new/183705377_Friday-15-March-1895-charge-of-kidnapping-william-manson-cases-supreme-court-crim
  9. customctx:genes/rosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/metadata-reingest/04-trove-nla-gov-au-newspaper-article-19829918-f6af5d5cd8e0
  10. [10]John Davis7 facts
    customctx:genes/trove-cooktown/john-davis
  11. [11]Cingalese6 facts
    customctx:genes/trove-cooktown/cingalese
  12. customctx:genes/rosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/trove-article-291085937
  13. [13]Prostitution4 facts
    customctx:genes/trove-cooktown/prostitution
  14. customctx:genes/rosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/trove-maytown-service-brought-rosey-children-3539375
  15. [15]Coloured Persons6 facts
    customctx:genes/trove-cooktown/coloured-persons
  16. customctx:genes/laura-corridor/loop10-reynolds-corridor
  17. ctx:genes/rosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-0978-eid-23581
  18. ctx:genes/trove-cooktown/north-shore-cooktown
  19. ctx:genes/brackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/trove-new/291085937_Friday-12-December-1890-telegraphic-news-cairns-dec-9
  20. ctx:genes/laura-corridor/loop11-hodgkinson
  21. ctx:genes/rosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/nmp-events-export-20260508193632/row-1987-eid-56231
  22. ctx:genes/trove-cooktown/north-shore-full
  23. [23]Watkins1 fact
    ctx:genes/trove-cooktown/watkins
  24. ctx:genes/trove-cooktown/mauritius-queensland
  25. [25]Loop9 Stations1 fact
    ctx:genes/laura-corridor/loop9-stations
  26. ctx:genes/brackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/trove-new/3579503_Thursday-10-May-1894-the-ministerial-party

See also

Keep researching

Missing something or suspicious of what's here? Kick off a research session — a Claude agent will investigate, cite its sources, and file new facts into a dedicated context you can review before accepting into the shared view.