Dontopedia
Explore

Sir Charles Lilley

From Dontopedia, the open, paraconsistent wiki. (Last updated 2026-07-04.)

Sir Charles Lilley has 100 facts recorded in Dontopedia across 17 references, with 2 live disagreements.

100+ facts·96 predicates·17 sources·2 in dispute

Mostly:dismisses motion(2), criticizes(2), administered oath to(2)

Maturity scale raw canonical shape-checked rule-derived certified

Dismisses Motionin disputedismissesMotion

Criticizesin disputecriticizes

Administered Oath toadministeredOathTo

Accompanied byaccompaniedBy

Chief Justicechief-justice

Chairs MeetingchairsMeeting

  • Gymnasium[12]all time · Trove James Reynolds Cattle Creek Mowbray Hotel 286435333

Directed VerdictdirectedVerdict

Died on DatediedOnDate

  • 1897-08-20[15]all time · 172385759 Friday 31 December 1897 Obituary 1897 Queensland

Had Age at DeathhadAgeAtDeath

  • 67[15]all time · 172385759 Friday 31 December 1897 Obituary 1897 Queensland

Had Previous RolehadPreviousRole

Died at AgediedAtAge

  • 67[14]all time · 187445219 Friday 7 January 1898

Died in MonthdiedInMonth

Inbound mentions (56)

Other subjects in dontopedia point AT this entity as a value. These are inverse relationships — e.g. "X motherOf this subject" — and answer questions the forward facts can't. Grouped by predicate.

presidedByPresided by(8)

beforeJudgeBefore Judge(3)

carriedPassengerCarried Passenger(3)

appearedBeforeAppeared Before(2)

beforeBefore(2)

hasPassengerHas Passenger(2)

includesIncludes(2)

presidedOverByPresided Over by(2)

advocatedAsBonaFideAdvocated As Bona Fide(1)

agreesWithAgrees With(1)

assistedAssisted(1)

assistedInOathAdministrationAssisted in Oath Administration(1)

authoredDocumentAuthored Document(1)

beforeJudgesBefore Judges(1)

carriesNotablePassengersCarries Notable Passengers(1)

cheeredVociferouslyCheered Vociferously(1)

citedInJudgmentCited in Judgment(1)

consideredUselessToInduceConsidered Useless to Induce(1)

describedAsEvilCounsellorDescribed As Evil Counsellor(1)

echoedTributeEchoed Tribute(1)

evaluatedByEvaluated by(1)

givesLeaveToApplyOnLawQuestionsGives Leave to Apply on Law Questions(1)

grantedAsPrayedGranted As Prayed(1)

grantedPermissionGranted Permission(1)

grosslyInadequateGrossly Inadequate(1)

heardBeforeHeard Before(1)

hearingBeforeHearing Before(1)

highlyEulogisedHighly Eulogised(1)

inInsolvencyBeforeIn Insolvency Before(1)

isIs(1)

isSonOfIs Son of(1)

judgedNotImproperByJudged Not Improper by(1)

likelyIdenticalToLikely Identical to(1)

paidTributeToPaid Tribute to(1)

preferredOverPenalServitudeByPreferred Over Penal Servitude by(1)

presidingJudgePresiding Judge(1)

rdf:typeRdf:type(1)

recklessOppressiveFraudulentReckless Oppressive Fraudulent(1)

reservesPowerToJudgeReserves Power to Judge(1)

triedBeforeTried Before(1)

Other facts (84)

The long tail: predicates that appear too rarely to warrant their own section. Filter or scroll to find a specific one. Each row links to its source.

84 facts
PredicateValueRef
Died in Year1897[14]
Died on1897-08-20[14]
Had TitleSir[14]
Has Age at Death67[14]
Comments on Press Influence DiminishingMoral Weight of Previous Judgments[9]
Criticizes Press forInjudicious Comments[9]
Attributes Motion to Witness InfluenceJoshua Grafton Smith[1]
Certain of PerjuryJoshua Grafton Smith[1]
Concluded Future Property PassesFuture Acquired Property Clause[1]
Concluded Witness PerjuredJoshua Grafton Smith[1]
Delivers JudgmentJudgment Delivery[1]
Examined Authorities on PointFuture Acquired Property Clause[1]
Finds No Fraudulent DealingDisputed Goods[1]
Believed Transaction in Good FaithTrue[1]
Believes Transaction Good FaithBill of Sale 1881 02 16[1]
Came to Conclusion ThatBill of Sale Valid[1]
Concludes Advance Was MadeJohn Davis[1]
Concludes Future Property PassedFuture Acquired Property[1]
Criticizes Perjury ofJoshua Grafton Smith[1]
Evaluates Point As NiceMr Griffith Point[1]
Finds No Fraudulent Dealing WithGoods[1]
Awaited Griffith Intentwaiting to hear whether Mr. Griffith intended to push the case[1]
Believes Execution Dateexecuted on the day on which it bore date[1]
Current Viewthought it had gone on all grounds[1]
Announced Judgment Delivery atFull Court August 1[1]
Answered Question WithNo[1]
Asked Whetherdefendant in custody[1]
Criticized Course Asneither respectful nor dignified[1]
Deemed Coursediscourteous to the court and irregular[1]
Found Language PlainLicensed Distillers Act[1]
Avoids Penal ServitudePrisoners Sentences[9]
Criticizes Press CommentsPress Comments on Punishment[9]
Boarded ShipKeilawabba[11]
Believed Witness LyingSmith[10]
Granted Order for Rule Nisi onGeorge Down[3]
Granted Rule Calling onRobert Dath and Boordoodabin Board[3]
Granted Rule Nisi on Application ofMr Virgil Power[3]
Acknowledged Health ProposalYes[3]
Arranged tolead the labour party in the next Parliament[7]
Expressed Opinion ThatGovernment House Suitable for University[1]
Duty to Protest Solemnly Againstsuch a state of things[8]
Expressed Opinion DuringCriminal Sittings Supreme Court[8]
Granted RuleNisi on Robert Porter[1]
Advocated Common Sense AssessmentDamages Calculation[6]
Described Horses Ashighly sensitive creatures[6]
Entered Judgment forJohn Wilson Carey[6]
Chief Justice in Chambers1885-12-02[2]
Commits to Deonticno entitlement without improper board action[1]
Denies Relief BecauseBoard Proper[1]
Advocates forone sufficient standard of education with honours[7]
Answers Question1Queensland Act keeps professions distinct but permits cross-practice[7]
Answers Question2no actual experience, few attempted cross-practice[7]
Acknowledged Compliment Frombridge[1]
Destination1Sydney[1]
Certified for CostsMr John Hurley[2]
Gave Judgment forMr John Hurley[2]
Believes Sale FraudulentSale of Cytheria to Ryder[1]
Cannot Say Whetherenjoyed by James and Ryder jointly[1]
Concluded Sale atgross undervalue[1]
Declared Salefraudulent and void[1]
Decree Point1Declare the sale to have been a fraud and void[1]
Decree Point2plaintiff entitled to redeem within six months[1]
Decree Point3account of principal and interest, property assigned on payment[1]
Decree Point4Louis Ryder[1]
Decree Point5injunction restraining defendants from dealing[1]
Decree Point6alternative damages, value £4 per head for 1700 head[1]
Did Not Believe WitnessGrafton Smith[1]
First DeclarationSale Fraudulent Void[1]
Gave JudgmentHolland V James and Others[1]
Gives Leave to AmendPleadings[1]
Cited CaseHolroyd V Marshall[1]
Found Advance Madethought an advance was actually made[1]
Found No Fraudulent Dealingdid not think there had been any fraudulent dealing with the goods[1]
Found No Sacrifice Salegoods were sold at a sacrifice[1]
Found PerjuryJoshua Grafton Smith[1]
Found Sufficient Noticeinsufficient notice of the sale had been given[1]
Gave Judgment onthis morning[1]
Announced Court Constitutionhimself and Mr. Justice Harding under statute[1]
Believes Advance MadeJohn Davis[1]
Considered Address NecessaryAttorney General Address[10]
Advocates Strictadministration of justice[8]
Criticizes Petitioner EntitlementAlexander Costello[1]
Former TitleChief Justice of Queensland[17]
Gave Judgment Against["ex:mrs-hall","ex:t-h-harris"][4]

Timeline

Timeline axis is valid_time — when each source says the fact was true in the world, not when Dontopedia learned about it. Retracted rows are kept for provenance; coloured stripes indicate the context kind.

accompaniedBytrove-cooktown/john-davis
ex:mr-edwyn-lilley
accompaniedBytrove-cooktown/cingalese
ex:mr-edwyn-lilley
acknowledgedComplimentFromtrove-cooktown/john-davis
bridge
acknowledgedHealthProposaltrove-cooktown/prostitution
ex:yes
administeredOathTotrove-cooktown/north-shore-cooktown
ex:sir-arthur-palmer
administeredOathTorosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/trove-peer-carriers-packers-blackboy-native-guide-67948700
ex:sir-arthur-palmer
advocatedCommonSenseAssessmenttrove-cooktown/beche-de-mer
ex:damages-calculation
advocatesFortrove-cooktown/coloured-persons
one sufficient standard of education with honours
advocatesStricttrove-cooktown/oliver-wates
administration of justice
announcedCourtConstitutiontrove-cooktown/john-davis
himself and Mr. Justice Harding under statute
announcedJudgmentDeliveryAttrove-cooktown/john-davis
ex:full-court-august-1
answeredQuestionWithtrove-cooktown/john-davis
No
answersQuestion1trove-cooktown/coloured-persons
Queensland Act keeps professions distinct but permits cross-practice
answersQuestion2trove-cooktown/coloured-persons
no actual experience, few attempted cross-practice
arrangedTotrove-cooktown/coloured-persons
lead the labour party in the next Parliament
askedWhethertrove-cooktown/john-davis
defendant in custody
attributesMotionToWitnessInfluencetrove-cooktown/john-davis
ex:joshua-grafton-smith
avoidsPenalServitudetrove-cooktown/north-shore-full
ex:prisoners-sentences
awaitedGriffithIntenttrove-cooktown/john-davis
waiting to hear whether Mr. Griffith intended to push the case
believedTransactionInGoodFaithtrove-cooktown/john-davis
ex:true
believedWitnessLyingtrove-cooktown/davis-cooktown
ex:smith
believesAdvanceMadetrove-cooktown/john-davis
ex:john-davis
believesExecutionDatetrove-cooktown/john-davis
executed on the day on which it bore date
believesSaleFraudulenttrove-cooktown/john-davis
ex:sale-of-cytheria-to-ryder
believesTransactionGoodFaithtrove-cooktown/john-davis
ex:bill-of-sale-1881-02-16
boardedShiptrove-cooktown/nunn
ex:keilawabba
cameToConclusionThattrove-cooktown/john-davis
ex:bill-of-sale-valid
cannotSayWhethertrove-cooktown/john-davis
enjoyed by James and Ryder jointly
certainOfPerjurytrove-cooktown/john-davis
ex:joshua-grafton-smith
certifiedForCoststrove-cooktown/cingalese
ex:mr-john-hurley
chairsMeetingrosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/trove-james-reynolds-cattle-creek-mowbray-hotel-286435333
ex:gymnasium
chief-justicerosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/trove-james-reynolds-cattle-creek-mowbray-hotel-4485717
ex:adjudicated-richard-mitchell
chiefJusticeInChamberstrove-cooktown/cingalese
1885-12-02
citedCasetrove-cooktown/john-davis
ex:holroyd-v-marshall
commentsOnPressInfluenceDiminishingtrove-cooktown/north-shore-full
ex:moral-weight-of-previous-judgments
commitsToDeontictrove-cooktown/john-davis
no entitlement without improper board action
concludedFuturePropertyPassestrove-cooktown/john-davis
ex:future-acquired-property-clause
concludedSaleAttrove-cooktown/john-davis
gross undervalue
concludedWitnessPerjuredtrove-cooktown/john-davis
ex:joshua-grafton-smith
concludesAdvanceWasMadetrove-cooktown/john-davis
ex:john-davis
concludesFuturePropertyPassedtrove-cooktown/john-davis
ex:future-acquired-property
consideredAddressNecessarytrove-cooktown/davis-cooktown
ex:attorney-general-address
criticizedCourseAstrove-cooktown/john-davis
neither respectful nor dignified
criticizestrove-cooktown/oliver-wates
ex:executive-interference-sentences
criticizestrove-cooktown/oliver-wates
ex:offenders-probation-act
criticizesPerjuryOftrove-cooktown/john-davis
ex:joshua-grafton-smith
criticizesPetitionerEntitlementtrove-cooktown/john-davis
ex:alexander-costello
criticizesPressCommentstrove-cooktown/north-shore-full
ex:press-comments-on-punishment
criticizesPressFortrove-cooktown/north-shore-full
ex:injudicious-comments
currentViewtrove-cooktown/john-davis
thought it had gone on all grounds
declaredSaletrove-cooktown/john-davis
fraudulent and void
decreePoint1trove-cooktown/john-davis
Declare the sale to have been a fraud and void
decreePoint2trove-cooktown/john-davis
plaintiff entitled to redeem within six months
decreePoint3trove-cooktown/john-davis
account of principal and interest, property assigned on payment
decreePoint4trove-cooktown/john-davis
ex:louis-ryder
decreePoint5trove-cooktown/john-davis
injunction restraining defendants from dealing
decreePoint6trove-cooktown/john-davis
alternative damages, value £4 per head for 1700 head
deemedCoursetrove-cooktown/john-davis
discourteous to the court and irregular
deliversJudgmenttrove-cooktown/john-davis
ex:judgment-delivery
deniesReliefBecausetrove-cooktown/john-davis
ex:board-proper
describedHorsesAstrove-cooktown/beche-de-mer
highly sensitive creatures
destination1trove-cooktown/john-davis
ex:sydney
didNotBelieveWitnesstrove-cooktown/john-davis
ex:grafton-smith
diedAtAgebrackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/north-shore-reynolds/187445219_Friday-7-January-1898
67
diedInMonthbrackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/north-shore-reynolds/187445219_Friday-7-January-1898
ex:august-1897
diedInYearbrackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/north-shore-reynolds/187445219_Friday-7-January-1898
1897
diedOnbrackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/north-shore-reynolds/187445219_Friday-7-January-1898
1897-08-20
diedOnDatebrackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/trove-new/172385759_Friday-31-December-1897_Obituary-1897-QUEENSLAND
1897-08-20
directedVerdictbrackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/trove-new/174762495_Saturday-7-May-1887_Our-Maryborough-Letter-May-2
ex:not-guilty-verdict
dismissesMotiontrove-cooktown/john-davis
ex:motion-in-insolvency
dismissesMotiontrove-cooktown/john-davis
ex:motion-to-set-aside-bill
dutyToProtestSolemnlyAgainsttrove-cooktown/oliver-wates
such a state of things
enteredJudgmentFortrove-cooktown/beche-de-mer
ex:john-wilson-carey
evaluatesPointAsNicetrove-cooktown/john-davis
ex:mr-griffith-point
examinedAuthoritiesOnPointtrove-cooktown/john-davis
ex:future-acquired-property-clause
expressedOpinionDuringtrove-cooktown/oliver-wates
ex:criminal-sittings-supreme-court
expressedOpinionThattrove-cooktown/john-davis
ex:government-house-suitable-for-university
findsNoFraudulentDealingtrove-cooktown/john-davis
ex:disputed-goods
findsNoFraudulentDealingWithtrove-cooktown/john-davis
ex:goods
firstDeclarationtrove-cooktown/john-davis
ex:sale-fraudulent-void
formerTitledocument/0311adf1-1bf3-4446-9eb0-1685afe32503
Chief Justice of Queensland
foundAdvanceMadetrove-cooktown/john-davis
thought an advance was actually made
foundLanguagePlaintrove-cooktown/john-davis
ex:licensed-distillers-act
foundNoFraudulentDealingtrove-cooktown/john-davis
did not think there had been any fraudulent dealing with the goods
foundNoSacrificeSaletrove-cooktown/john-davis
goods were sold at a sacrifice
foundPerjurytrove-cooktown/john-davis
ex:joshua-grafton-smith
foundSufficientNoticetrove-cooktown/john-davis
insufficient notice of the sale had been given
gaveJudgmenttrove-cooktown/john-davis
ex:holland-v-james-and-others
gaveJudgmentAgainsttrove-cooktown/north-shore-cooktown
["ex:mrs-hall","ex:t-h-harris"]
gaveJudgmentFortrove-cooktown/cingalese
ex:mr-john-hurley
gaveJudgmentOntrove-cooktown/john-davis
this morning
givesLeaveToAmendtrove-cooktown/john-davis
ex:pleadings
grantedOrderForRuleNisiOntrove-cooktown/prostitution
ex:george-down
grantedRuletrove-cooktown/john-davis
ex:nisi-on-robert-porter
grantedRuleCallingOntrove-cooktown/prostitution
ex:robert-dath-and-boordoodabin-board
grantedRuleNisiOnApplicationOftrove-cooktown/prostitution
ex:mr-virgil-power
hadAgeAtDeathbrackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/trove-new/172385759_Friday-31-December-1897_Obituary-1897-QUEENSLAND
67
hadPreviousRolebrackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/north-shore-reynolds/187445219_Friday-7-January-1898
ex:chief-justice-queensland
hadTitlebrackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/north-shore-reynolds/187445219_Friday-7-January-1898
Sir
hasAgeAtDeathbrackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/north-shore-reynolds/187445219_Friday-7-January-1898
67

References (17)

17 references
  1. [1]John Davis57 facts
    customctx:genes/trove-cooktown/john-davis
  2. [2]Cingalese4 facts
    customctx:genes/trove-cooktown/cingalese
  3. [3]Prostitution4 facts
    customctx:genes/trove-cooktown/prostitution
  4. customctx:genes/trove-cooktown/north-shore-cooktown
  5. customctx:genes/rosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/trove-peer-carriers-packers-blackboy-native-guide-67948700
  6. [6]Beche De Mer3 facts
    customctx:genes/trove-cooktown/beche-de-mer
  7. customctx:genes/trove-cooktown/coloured-persons
  8. [8]Oliver Wates5 facts
    customctx:genes/trove-cooktown/oliver-wates
  9. customctx:genes/trove-cooktown/north-shore-full
  10. [10]Davis Cooktown2 facts
    customctx:genes/trove-cooktown/davis-cooktown
  11. [11]Nunn1 fact
    customctx:genes/trove-cooktown/nunn
  12. customctx:genes/rosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/trove-james-reynolds-cattle-creek-mowbray-hotel-286435333
  13. customctx:genes/rosie-reynolds-massacre-connection/trove-james-reynolds-cattle-creek-mowbray-hotel-4485717
  14. customctx:genes/brackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/north-shore-reynolds/187445219_Friday-7-January-1898
  15. customctx:genes/brackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/trove-new/172385759_Friday-31-December-1897_Obituary-1897-QUEENSLAND
  16. customctx:genes/brackenridge-cairns-1880-1900/trove-new/174762495_Saturday-7-May-1887_Our-Maryborough-Letter-May-2
  17. ctx:claims/document/0311adf1-1bf3-4446-9eb0-1685afe32503

See also

Keep researching

Missing something or suspicious of what's here? Kick off a research session — a Claude agent will investigate, cite its sources, and file new facts into a dedicated context you can review before accepting into the shared view.